I repeat, if Sony put the machine behind Amerie she would still be relevant today. The radio don't play Beyoncé's records because they are just so great musically. A lot goes into making sure she stays in rotation. A lot goes into making sure she gets performances at every awards show. If Beyoncé left Sony today and went independent you would see just how little talent matters in the grand scheme of things. As big as Beyoncé is and as business saavy that she is, please tell me why you don't think she's left Sony by now if she could accomplish the same shyt independently and keep all the money? As soon as she does that the radio spins go away as well as the MTV awards and the Grammy Performances and all the perks of being backed by a major. Jay is her husband, why not sign to Roc Nation and get independent distribution if all she needs is her talent and looks?
I like how you underestimate the brand she's built as well as the tens of millions of fans who adore her. You need to have the "it" factor or intangibles as well as the technical execution...the promotional push is just icing on the cake. Her fans didn't like her just cuz she got promo (Cassie and Tierra Marie both get/got pushes from their labels, yet they suck so fans aren't buying it) her fans got her to the point of where she's at cuz she's a BOSS at what she does.
And stop with the "take away the major label" bullshyt, damn near all transcendent artists are/were on a major - Michael Jackson, janet, Mariah, whitney, Madonna, Britney, Rihanna, Celine dion, etc. - and no one handicaps their chart performance or accomplishments because of it. ,that independent shyt is for nikkas/internet famous artists who can't get signed to lucrative deals from the majors so they rationalize their status on an independent.