VegetasHairline
Veteran
Pro Bowls! 


Well if you believe he didn’t have a HOF career before the “fall off”( I disagree, there are other HOF QBs without the accolades you mentioned above) Then that’s different from saying he “played himself out of the HOF”I dont agree with that.
No MVPs
No All Pros
Doesn't hold any major records
Not elite relative to peers
People bring up pro bowls because that's his biggest individual accomplishment.
Now i would agree that early on he was on the path, just never really materialized.
Well if you believe he didn’t have a HOF career before the “fall off”( I disagree, there are other HOF QBs without the accolades you mentioned above) Then that’s different from saying he “played himself out of the HOF”
The implication in saying that is, that if he retired a couple years ago he’d get in, but now he doesn’t deserve to make it cause a few bad seasons at the end of his career.
If Eli's getting in(and Eli's getting in), Russ is getting in.I dont agree with that.
No MVPs
No All Pros
Doesn't hold any major records
Not elite relative to peers
People bring up pro bowls because that's his biggest individual accomplishment.
Now i would agree that early on he was on the path, just never really materialized.
Eli doesn't deserve to get in.If Eli's getting in(and Eli's getting in), Russ is getting in.
I completely agree but he's definitely getting in. If Eli gets in then I don't see how Russ isn't getting in.Eli doesn't deserve to get in.
If he does it's just him being a Manning and having ties to Brady's legacy. Russ doesn't have that, although i do think he'd be in if they beat Brady.
Eli is a fraud, glad he didn't get first ballot.
Eli doesn't deserve to get in.
If he does it's just him being a Manning and having ties to Brady's legacy. Russ doesn't have that, although i do think he'd be in if they beat Brady.
Eli is a fraud, glad he didn't get first ballot.


Russ once threw 4 interceptions in a playoff game and they still one. Sherman is correct.
you gotta score to win*
Be fair and also point out how they had the lead on the Patriots in the Super Bowl and that legendary defense gave it away.
Sherman was on the 9ers vs KC in the Super Bowl and got cooked by Sammy Watkins which a was major play on the comeback victory.
Everyone who's ever played the game has bad moments. You don't go out of your way to point that out especially after you want a championship with that player. I don't see ex Cowboys saying how the O-line, Emmitt, and Playmaker carried Aikman. The Ravens don't even do Trent Dilfer like that.
Black QB's stay getting respected at the end of their career and people need to get called out for that. From McNabb to Cam Newton and now Russ. Give them the same grace you give white QB's.
Russ is absolutely better than EliId put Russell in before Eli
You don’t throw over 57,000 yards and top ten in TDs all time as a fraud. Eli shyts on RussEli doesn't deserve to get in.
If he does it's just him being a Manning and having ties to Brady's legacy. Russ doesn't have that, although i do think he'd be in if they beat Brady.
Eli is a fraud, glad he didn't get first ballot.