Elway was overrated right?

mastermind

mastermind

Rest In Power Kobe
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
65,400
Reputation
6,509
Daps
174,846
K-Apps said:
A NY sports radio host I listen to daily said this week that Elway was comparable to Mahomes based on ability, but that Mahomes is considered better because the Chiefs with Andy Reid are better than those 80s Broncos teams that could killed by WAS, Giants, and 49ers. I was like :what: :mjlol: listening to that. Elway was physically talented player no doubt, but even in his prime his stats were average at best. Pundits like Wilbon talk him up like he’s one of the greats and it’s just wasn’t true. Someone in the AFC in the 80s had to take those losses in the Super Bowl and the Broncos were that team three times.
Click to expand...
Josh Allen>John Elway

Allen is a souped up elway
 
get these nets

get these nets

Veteran
Joined
Jul 8, 2017
Messages
58,770
Reputation
16,267
Daps
214,534
Reppin
Above the fray.
Elway was an exciting player. Had lot of memorable comebacks and clutch moments.
Great athlete. He used to "win with his legs" and scramble and run for 1st downs all the time.
I cringed when the same broadcasters started using that phrase to undermine Black QBs years later, having never used it for Elway or Steve Young.

He made 5 Superbowl appearances, so you can't really call him over rated. Somebody dominated the AFC playoffs those years.
 
Last edited:
P

prime

Superstar
Joined
Jun 8, 2013
Messages
7,751
Reputation
1,312
Daps
20,364
Reppin
The heights
I'm My uncle is a elway Stan and thinks base on pure talent elway is the GOAT he always said if the 49ers colts traded would've went thru in the 1983 draft elway would've been the goat but people need to look the the teams elway dragged in the Super Bowl in the 80s :scusthov:
 
R

ReturnOfJudah

Veteran
Joined
Nov 25, 2014
Messages
41,895
Reputation
-840
Daps
122,022
K-Apps said:
A NY sports radio host I listen to daily said this week that Elway was comparable to Mahomes based on ability, but that Mahomes is considered better because the Chiefs with Andy Reid are better than those 80s Broncos teams that could killed by WAS, Giants, and 49ers. I was like :what: :mjlol: listening to that. Elway was physically talented player no doubt, but even in his prime his stats were average at best. Pundits like Wilbon talk him up like he’s one of the greats and it’s just wasn’t true. Someone in the AFC in the 80s had to take those losses in the Super Bowl and the Broncos were that team three times.
Click to expand...
Elway 2x as better than Mahomes. Without the refs Mahomes is mid

mastermind said:
Josh Allen>John Elway

Allen is a souped up elway
Click to expand...

Allen is faster. Thats the only thing hes better at than Elway
 
Street Knowledge

Street Knowledge

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
27,539
Reputation
2,568
Daps
66,498
Reppin
NYC
KidJSoul said:
I think what helps Elway is just how DRASTIC his stats increase was with Shanahan

It made people realize "hmm, maybe Elway could have been putting up better numbers if he had a better oc/system :lupe: "


Remember: Joe Montana, Steve Young, and Brett Favre ALL played on west coast offenses that are KNOWN for generating easy completions. That boosts efficiency (completion percentage, yards, lowers int %).

Look at Mahomes this year and how the Chiefs offense is largely just schemes up drag routes

The Marino offense in Miami was spread out with Marino throwing downfield to wicked fast receivers against basic run-stopping defenses

Meanwhile Elway played in an old school run first pass second offense
Click to expand...
He was still blown out the water by the elite QBs in his time

Like with Shanny he graduated to peak Bernie Kosar Status
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top