An atheist or religionist would tend to believe that injustice is predetermined. A religionist would believe that it is part of God’s plan, while an atheist would believe that an injustice represents nothing more than a random event, something that was, in effect, predetermined by the big bang.
Christians when faced with evil or the death of their loved ones via murder, diseased, etc.. say that God is all-loving but not omnipotent. They take the position that God is a good guy, but impotent, BUT God is either all-knowing and all-powerful, or He is not God.
atheists argue that If God does not know there is evil, he is not omniscient. If God knows there is evil but cannot prevent it, he is not omnipotent. If God knows there is evil and can prevent it but desires not to, he is not omni-aything. If … God is all-knowing and all-powerful, we must conclude that God is not all-good. The existence of evil in the universe excludes this possibility.
I say that God knows there is evil in the world, but does not choose to stop it for reasons that are beyond our understanding. In other words, God alone knows why He does what He does. If God exists, He is unknowable and undefinable by human standards. That, after all, is precisely what makes him God.
Consider the possibility that man is to God as a dog is to man, and a dog is to man as a tick is to a dog; i.e., the man, the dog, and the tick, who are merely tagging along for the ride, have neither the faintest idea as to why their masters do what they do nor the means to ever understand why.
it is arrogance to suggest that we should be able to understand evil and suffering, let alone make judgments about the actions of a Supreme Being. If there is a God, surely He operates in a completely different dimension than we do, thus He alone knows His purpose.
The atheist definition of God & Evil is valid only in a secular dimension. A Supreme Being would, by definition, transcend secular knowledge, just as man transcends a dog’s capacity to understand human reasoning.
In any event, it would be inconsistent to believe in God, yet question perceived evil and injustice. Only God can know the reasons for the existence of evil and injustice. Of course, if one is an atheist, he has no choice but to accept random evil and injustice as natural aspects of life.
Whatever our assumptions may be, the bottom line is that life can, indeed, be unjust, as the deaths of millions of slaves, the deaths of children, etc..