How those Mcnabb years looking now Eagles Fans......

[Born2BKing]

They boo'd that nikka the damn day he was drafted. No coach or player should want to play for those shytty as fans up there.

 

[Dr. Fauci]

im not reading this whole thread...but are people seriously saying the Eagles shouldnt of traded him??

We saw what happened to him afterwards...

Mcnab's problem was always that he came up short....threw up in the Superbowl...that was the knock on him

I agree that he never had recievers, and when we finally gave him one, we went to the Superbowl...ill never understand that from the Eagles franchise. But if ure saying we shoulda kept him, i dont know what to say

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

Man, fukk the trade. He was clearly on the decline when that trade went down....and I have mad respect for Mcnabb.

My problem is with how he was treated during his prime. Unfairly killed nationally, and his own fan base didn't stick up for him. Disgusting.

 

[Rapmastermind]

People are saying he was on the Decline. His last 2 years on the Eagles he was in the Playoffs Both Years and even went back to the NFC Title game. There's no way the Eagles don't make the Playoffs with Donovan last couple of years. He knew our system in and out. Also Donovan has a very low INT and Fumble ratio. People making fun of his worm killing dirt balls but those throws saved a lot of picks QB's end of throwing he doesn't. If those are Down years I want more of them cause it seems The Eagles are in the Down Years now.

 

[feelosofer]

I been saying for years the Eagle's and the their fans didn't appreciate Black excellence. Even when McNabb took ya'll to a Super Bowl ya'll dudes were stanning for TO blaming McNabb for losing.

Lol at dudes saying McNabb was on the decline when they traded him, dude had less weapons and a worse offense line in Washington until that racist Shanahan benched the dude after a 4-2 start.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

People are saying he was on the Decline. His last 2 years on the Eagles he was in the Playoffs Both Years and even went back to the NFC Title game. There's no way the Eagles don't make the Playoffs with Donovan last couple of years. He knew our system in and out. Also Donovan has a very low INT and Fumble ratio. People making fun of his worm killing dirt balls but those throws saved a lot of picks QB's end of throwing he doesn't. If those are Down years I want more of them cause it seems The Eagles are in the Down Years now.

They traded him cuz they had Vick....not cuz Mcnabb sucked. It was better to cut ties a little too soon than a little too late.

It's not about Mcnabb sucking, its about him being past his prime and them having a serviceable/good QB to replace him with. Even if you don't agree with the trade, you're lying to yourself I'd you act like you can't see the "football reasons" in why they made.

During his prime, there was no reason for the way that fan base treated him.

 

[Rapmastermind]

They boo'd that nikka the damn day he was drafted. No coach or player should want to play for those shytty as fans up there.

I still can't believed the boo'ed the guy that ended up winning them over 100 games during his time there:

​

 

[phillycavsfan]

Man, fukk the trade. He was clearly on the decline when that trade went down....and I have mad respect for Mcnabb.

My problem is with how he was treated during his prime. Unfairly killed nationally, and his own fan base didn't stick up for him. Disgusting.

How should we have "stuck up for him"? Sign a petition honoring him?

 

[phillycavsfan]

They boo'd that nikka the damn day he was drafted. No coach or player should want to play for those shytty as fans up there.

That's wasn't our fukking fault. The morning radio show on WIP (who have always hated McNabb and his mom) sent 30 of their biggest fans to New York to boo anyone not named Ricky Williams.

Those fukkboys got excoriated for that shyt on and off air, and rightfully so. The one guy who had his face painted got singled out, and he gets harassed at every Eagles game for doing that dumb shyt.

 

[phillycavsfan]

I been saying for years the Eagle's and the their fans didn't appreciate Black excellence. Even when McNabb took ya'll to a Super Bowl ya'll dudes were stanning for TO blaming McNabb for losing.

Well, TO had 5 catches and 100 yards on a broken leg in the Super Bowl. McNabb threw 3 picks and was hyperventilating during the key drive in the game.

 

[FTBS]

You're not going to force me into a position to denigrating McNabb, but to say he "OWNED" is isn't putting in it's proper perspective.

Between 1999-2006, the Giants only had 3 seasons with records above .500; Dallas had 3; the Redskins had 3 and the Eagles had 6.

During McNabb's NFC championship years, (with the exception of the Giants in 2000), their division rivals made the playoffs maybe ONCE each in those four years.

To put it in plain english, their competition sucked. But that doesn't take away from what he has accomplished and brought to the city--if you're old enough to remember, I don't recall anyone putting him down for that. His "history" is put in it's proper perspective. What eventually ruined his legacy is the fact that he had been dropped and traded several times before being barred from the league altogether. Ironically, like Iverson, the END of his career is the lasting impression that people have.

As a matter of fact, everyone supported him while he carried the team on his back in that era. Everyone critisized the administration for NOT given him any weapons to work with which eventually brought on TO. But as time went on...people were simply TIRED of his BS and his underacheiving in the post season after around 2006 or so. This is one of those times where numbers just do not tell the whole story. His play making decisions in crunch time situations are what brought criticism to his playing style and his eventual replacement.

Like Reid, he has accomplished a lot in Philly, but the bottomline is still the bottomline. You can recite statistics all day until the sun rises, but people in Philly are restless for a championship and I think it was pretty crystal clear that it was NOT going to happen with him there. Some of his rabid defenders just need to understand and accept that small factoid.

nikkas just go to any lengths to shyt on this nikka. I've never heard the quality if a division used to diminish the winner. Especially if that teams makes noise in the playoffs. Most teams in this league are inconsistent from year to year. Generally the teams with best and most consistent QB is gonna dominate the division while the other teams will be up and down. How strong was the AFC south from year to year when Manning was dominating it? How strong has the AFC East been as Brady has ran shyt? The NFC East during that time was at the very least comparable so that's just a silly to even bring that up. Only difference between then and now is that the Eagles aren't running shyt.


It's funny how nikkas keep bringing up the last two years in WAS and MIN as if that has anything to do with Philly. Donovan knew that offense inside and out. His last year there he put up 22 and 10 and 3550 yds on 60% completions and they went 11-5. He goes to WAS with a new offense, no recievers, and no running game and throwing 40 times a game and that didn't work? I wonder why. You take Manning or Brady and put them in new offenses with no weapons and no running game and have them throwing it 40 times a game and they would struggle too. Maybe not to the degree that Mcnabb did because they are more accurate than him however they would certainly struggle. There is no doubt in my mind that McNabb would have flourished in Philly if given more than one season with Jackson/Maclin/McCoy. Andy ed his ass and I really can't be mad at Donovan for shytting on him (If that's what he's doing. I haven't heard it but sure would like to ). He should have been spoke up.

 

[Born2BKing]

Outside of T.O. who the hell did McNabb have to throw to all those years? And what happened when he did get T.O.? Superbowl appearance.

 

[Rapmastermind]

nikkas just go to any lengths to shyt on this nikka. I've never heard the quality if a division used to diminish the winner. Especially if that teams makes noise in the playoffs. Most teams in this league are inconsistent from year to year. Generally the teams with best and most consistent QB is gonna dominate the division while the other teams will be up and down. How strong was the AFC south from year to year when Manning was dominating it? How strong has the AFC East been as Brady has ran shyt? The NFC East during that time was at the very least comparable so that's just a silly to even bring that up. Only difference between then and now is that the Eagles aren't running shyt.


It's funny how nikkas keep bringing up the last two years in WAS and MIN as if that has anything to do with Philly. Donovan knew that offense inside and out. His last year there he put up 22 and 10 and 3550 yds on 60% completions and they went 11-5. He goes to WAS with a new offense, no recievers, and no running game and throwing 40 times a game and that didn't work? I wonder why. You take Manning or Brady and put them in new offenses with no weapons and no running game and have them throwing it 40 times a game and they would struggle too. Maybe not to the degree that Mcnabb did because they are more accurate than him however they would certainly struggle. There is no doubt in my mind that McNabb would have flourished in Philly if given more than one season with Jackson/Maclin/McCoy. Andy ed his ass and I really can't be mad at Donovan for shytting on him (If that's what he's doing. I haven't heard it but sure would like to ). He should have been spoke up.

Exactly I can't believe dudes are using "Quality of the Division" to discredit Donovan's run. As if Brady and Peyton's Divisions were lighting it up. If you think about During Donovan's Time, Dallas and The Giants made it to the playoffs 5 and 3 times so it's not like the whole Division was trash. Only the Skins didn't make it to the playoffs that much and even then they still got there 2 times. The NFC EAST always sent about 2 teams during Donovan's time but most than not he was the Going. The Biggest reason The Giants, Skins and Boys failed to not make it to the Superbowl was during that time they couldn't Beat The Donovan Lead Eagles cause he won the most Division titles and had the most playoff appearances.

 

[phillycavsfan]

You can only beat who's in front of you.

 

[Rapmastermind]

Outside of T.O. who the hell did McNabb have to throw to all those years? And what happened when he did get T.O.? Superbowl appearance.

And the Eagles never had a POWER running game. It more a finesse running game with Dunce and Westbrook mostly catching screens but they both were good running backs.