If Aaliyah was still here, do you think she would be the best female artist in R&B/Pop right now?

[feelosofer]

I liked Aaliyahs music but I don't know if she'd be at the top of the R&B game in 2017, if she were still alive.

 

[sporticus]

Like has been said already, she'd probably be done musically or have a modest career. Like most artists, death pumped up her stature.

 

[Wacky D]

That was terrible.

let @JustCKing tell it, she sounded like whitney in that clip.

 

[DMGAINGREEN]

My nicca Wack in here still tryna vigorously convince niccas Aaliyah was some underground Z list artist

 

[Cynic]

If Aaliyah had the same promotion that Beyonce' has had for the last 2 decades, she could've been the best female artist in the game

Beyonce's team of A&R's and promotional team > Beyonce's talent

Beyonce' is talented but she's not as great as many make her out to be.

Her work ethic and ruthlessness is what makes her GOAT

 

[I love Latina women]

Her work ethic and ruthlessness is what makes her GOAT

She works her ass off but her music ain't all that to me.

 

[eastside313]

If Aaliyah had the same promotion that Beyonce' has had for the last 2 decades, she could've been the best female artist in the game

Beyonce's team of A&R's and promotional team > Beyonce's talent

Beyonce' is talented but she's not as great as many make her out to be.

lol Aaliyah was not on Beyoncé category. She couldn't sing or dance anywhere near Beyoncé.
She was more Ashanti type.

 

[Cynic]

She works her ass off but her music ain't all that to me.

I highly doubt you are her core audience breh but not too many females
can sing and follow those choreographed dance sequences flawlessly


and if they do...she's sharking their writers and songs on the low

 

[I love Latina women]

I highly doubt you are her core audience breh but not too many females
can sing and follow those choreographed dance sequences flawlessly


and if they do...she's sharking their writers and songs on the low

Beyonce can sing and dance. I just don't "feel" her singing. Only on 1 hand can I count the number of songs I've actually liked by her and it's like 3.

Dancing, yeah she good at that. She puts on 1 helluva show. But again, the vocals are just *there*.

I'm not saying she ain't talented, I just don't think she all that.

 

[I love Latina women]

lol Aaliyah was not on Beyoncé category. She couldn't sing or dance anywhere near Beyoncé.
She was more Ashanti type.

Aaliyah was just starting to warm up before she died. Yeah she had been on the scene since she was teenager but she really hadn't even reached her full potential when she died. Beyonce is a stronger singer than Aaliyah though they have different registers but I could "feel" Aaliyah's singing more. It seemed genuine. Beyonce's singing is just *there* to me.

 

[Cynic]

Beyonce can sing and dance. I just don't "feel" her singing. Only on 1 hand can I count the number of songs I've actually liked by her and it's like 3.

Dancing, yeah she good at that. She puts on 1 helluva show. But again, the vocals are just *there*.

I'm not saying she ain't talented, I just don't think she all that.

She does her job well... if she didn't do choreography maybe she'd have more time to dedicate to belting out ballads

but if you think that there's anybody who puts together a better package alive today then we're done

 

[I love Latina women]

She does her job well... if she didn't do choreography maybe she'd have more time to dedicate to belting out ballads

but if you think that there's anybody who puts together a better package alive today then we're done

But here's the thing tho, I don't think her singing is all that. It's not bad, but she ain't belting out like Whitney, Mariah or Toni did in their day.

Again, can she sing? Yes. But it's anything special to ME.

We gon just agree to disagree cause you got your opinion and I got mine. It's all good tho.

 

[Cynic]

But here's the thing tho, I don't think her singing is all that. It's not bad, but she ain't belting out like Whitney, Mariah or Toni did in their day.

Again, can she sing? Yes. But it's anything special to ME.

We gon just agree to disagree cause you got your opinion and I got mine. It's all good tho.

You seen Whitney, Mariah and Toni dance ?

 

[010101]

it's riri before riri
the music is good but it's the personality driving it
aaliyah was the "it girl" she'd be more than fine

*

 

[I love Latina women]

You seen Whitney, Mariah and Toni dance ?

Bruh. I didn't say nothing bout dancing. I was talking about singing when I made that last post. I broke it down before. I said Beyonce can sing and dance however I don't think her singing is anything like Whitney's, Mariah's or Toni's was. Her singing is bland to me. That's all.

She can do both but her singing ain't nothing I "feel".

I'm tired of repeating myself, bruh. lol