Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?

[Trojan 24]

Peak play yes, but saying that Carr might have outplayed him two games in a row now

 

[Th3G3ntleman]

Yea him and 2019 Joe Burrow

boy not even the best rookie in his class. Stop it

 

[Armchair Militant]

Rodgers

 

[Kinguno]

Yes because with his father being a MLB pitcher you can argue Patrick Mahomes was made to throw the football it’s Godly the way he is even when fukking around with no look off hand passing touchdowns.

I call him the Anni Skywalker of the NFL especially with him being an offsides play away from twice winning the AFC while Bill and Tom still breathing

 

[OnFleekTing]

if he wins another super bowl then he immediately begins a baby goat conversation but his career is just beginning and bad front office and injury and coaching decisions can keep him down for awhile
see rodgers, roethlisberger, and manning

 

[filial_piety]

No....but his career is still in it's infancy....I can't say until he does about 10 years or gets atleast 4 SB wins/with multiple league MVPs

The best year I've ever seen from a QB is 1994/95 Steve Young

The best to ever do it has to be Brady, or Montana

 

[Bennett80]

It is Rodgers. Mahomes has had the benefit of being surrounded by hof talent. Just look at his weapons, it is ridiculous.

 

[South Paw]

Yes.

Never has there been a player I have been more sure of after their first few games. When dude steps up in the pocket & cocks back you just a big play is coming.

Off the eye test he's top 3 for sure. Rese wise imo he would only need 1 or 2 more rings to solidify himself as the GOAT to me. That Chief's team last year wasn't built for super bowl contention. Defense was bad, running game was gimped etc.

Its rare for a team to get carried to a Lombardi soley off QB play when the rest of the team is bad. Its not supposed to happen. Look at Marino's career. "Defense wins championships". Pat did that last year with his arm. And not just the superbowl, the entire run. Including regular season.

Dude has my vote of confidence right now, no doubt he can win another 2 and snatch the title for sure

Their defense stepped up and is the main reason they won the chip. Pat just kept doing what he was doing

 

[Copy Ninja]

GOAT and best are different, so definitely not the GOAT as he's so young right now.

I absolutely see the argument of him being the best in terms of overall arm talent, mobility, etc.

I don't see the big difference between him and Rodgers though. It's not a knock on Mahomes, but he's been surrounded with a much better offensive cast, so it's sometimes tough to evaluate and compare him against Rodgers.

Prime Rodgers with Reid and the skill players they now have in KC would be

Mahomes is great but Prime Rodgers throwing was the best I've ever seen.

 

[South Paw]

Y'all still on that Rodgers

 

[Da_Eggman]

Marino

 

[South Paw]

Mahomes probably gonna get there but he in an amazing situation w those weapons and Reid. The other great qbs of today haven't had that luxury.

 

[FS4LFE]

I’m still taking peak Aaron Rodgers over him. But he nice.

 

[O.iatlhawksfan]

2009 Drew Brees was special

 

[desjardins]

naw
2010-2011 Vick
Ratings aren't far off and Vick actually still got popped by defenders and had lesser weapons imo