Is Mike Evans A HOF Player?

[Lord Beasley]

I agree with him

 

[BrehWyatt]

Julio
AB
Tyreek
DHop
AJ Green
Davante

I dont see a case for Evans over any of em... He probably next but there other nikkas who was clearly better peak for peak like Michael Thomas but Evans should be applauded for his longevity and consistency. Even if he was never a top tier WR1/2 candidate. Like there nikkas now like Jetta and Chase who are just better than Evans ever was even tho you obviously wouldnt rank either ahead of him all time as of 2023.

The best case for Evans over everyone here sans D-Hop is that no matter who is throwing him the ball, he's going to get his.

AB's primary QB is a future HOFer and a multiple-time Pro Bowler (Big Ben).
Tyreek's primary QB is a future HOFer, a multiple-time All-Pro, Pro Bowler and MVP (Mahomes).
Davante's primary QB is a future HOFer, a multiple-time All-Pro, Pro Bowler and MVP (Rodgers).
Julio's primary QB may not go to the HOF, but he is a multiple-time Pro Bowler, former MVP and All-Pro (Ryan).
AJ Green primary QB isn't going to the HOF, but he is a multiple-time Pro Bowler (Dalton).

Evans' primary QB -- this is defined as the QB he played the most games with -- is Jameis Winston. Mr. 30-for-30.

 

[Ohene]

This aint the nba. 2nd team doesnt count.

Yes it does idiot

 

[Mandizi]

He's right

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Yes it does idiot

No it doesnt, fakkit.

This not the nba. The only thing that matters is 1st team all pro.

 

[Ohene]

No it doesnt, fakkit.

This not the nba. The only thing that matters is 1st team all pro.

you actually might be right breh. my bad lol
but tell me why andre reed, and isaac bruce in the HOF then

 

[Ohene]

I agree with him

AJ Brown is better
So is Justin Jefferson

them the top 3

 

[Lord Beasley]

AJ Brown is better
So is Justin Jefferson

them the top 3

Simple answer:

Spoiler

 

[Ohene]

Simple answer:

Spoiler

yes lol
AJ brown has 3 straight 2nd team all pros
he's clearly the third best in the league
dont be foolish breh

 

[Lord Beasley]

yes lol
AJ brown has 3 straight 2nd team all pros
he's clearly the third best in the league
dont be foolish breh

we gon act like Mike Evans hasn't had shyt for QBs, with the exception of TB12. yet still on a streak of 1,000 yd seasons

 

[Doctor Doom]

They got Puka Top 3? Oh brother

Nico Collins

 

[JYoung24]

Evans is averaging 15.4 yards per catch for his career which is elite.

Then there’s who is throwing the ball to him. **** played with great quarterback play for the bulk of his career.

Evans has over 1,000 yards this year with 5 games left playing with Baker Mayfield.

What do you mean playing with mayfield mayfield is a qb you can get numbers with you act like he playing with alex smith

 

[JYoung24]

Man has had Mike Glennon, Josh McCown, Blind Jameis, Ryan Fitzpatrick, and Baker Mayfield

The best QB he had was a senior citizen and ya wondering why he doesn't have more All-pros

Ehh most of those qbs you named arent going to mess up your individual stats you cant win with them but if your a reciever you can put up numbers with them

 

[Bigwhite2498]

No he is not because I’m a hater of all things A&M but fr tho idk numbers wise yes but he just seems to get overlooked