Harden is a perennial choker, but he's better than Pierce was...
Pierce was an All-Star level player for a long time, but what was he doing that Harden wasn't? We know his defense was was a little better but Pierce wasn't some elite defender at any point. He isn't as unique a scorer as Harden, though I'd say Pierce had the more pure shot...
And Pierce also wasn't winning shyt, the same way Harden hasn't won shyt...
Harden just finished Year 10. Pierce won his title in Year 10, the year he got blessed with KG and Ray and didn't have to be the #1 anymore...
Pierce was never a true #1 and always better suited to be the second option, but in the seven years he was Boston's #1 (2000-2007/Year 3 thru Year 9), he never led his team to a 50-win season, missed the playoffs three times, only made the playoffs four times, was eliminated in the First Round two of those four playoff appearances, and only got to the East Finals once...
Harden became a #1 in Year 4 when he went to Houston and has been one since. Comparatively, in seven years as a #1 (2012-present/Year 4 thru Year 10), he's led his team to four 50-win and one 60-win seasons; has never missed the playoffs in the same equivalent time as a #1 as Pierce, which is more impressive given Harden has never missed the playoffs in the tougher conference while Pierce missed the playoffs three times in the '00s Eastern Conference...
Three of those playoffs Harden got eliminated in Round 1, but he also got to the West Finals twice...
At the same point in their career Pierce was a 5x All-Star and 2x All-NBA 3rd Team. Harden is a 7x All-Star, 6x All-NBA (5x 1st Team), 2x scoring champ, assists leader, and MVP...
Comparatively, both in the middle of their primes, as #1's, here's Paul Pierce (2000-2007):
(Reg season)
38.4 minutes per game
24.8/6.7/4.1 on 18.3 shots per game
.439/.358/.793 (8.8 FTA per game)
22 PER/.558 TS%
30.3 USG/29.9 VORP
42.9 OWS/25.5 DWS/68.5 WS
.161 WS/48
(Playoffs)
42.1 mpg
24.5/8.5/4.7 on 18 shots per game
.409/.301/.820 (10.1 FTA per game)
21.8 PER/.548 TS%
29.7 USG/2.8 VORP
2.6 OWS/2.7 DWS/5.3 WS
.162 WS/48
James Harden (2012-2019)
(Reg Season)
37.1 mpg
29/6/7.7 on 19.3 shots per game
.443/.364/.861 (10.2 FTA per game)
26.5 PER/.610 TS%
33 USG/53 VORP
77.4 OWS/23.6 DWS/100.9 WS
.239 WS/48
(Playoffs)
38.2 mpg
28.2/5.7/7 on 20.7 shots per game
.412/.322/.876 (9.4 FTA per game)
23.5 PER/.569 TS%
33.3 USG/6.3 VORP
6.5 OWS/2.8 DWS/9.3 WS
.161 WS/48