Albums Last 4 Jay Z's or Nas' efforts ?

[prophecypro]

Chill with this.

Im just happy both in their 4th decade making great music

 

[NV-ME]

w/o life is good, there is no 4:44

pay attention

 

[Formerly known as...]

I absolutely HATE MCHG, and for that Nas takes this.

Nasir isn't good but its 7 tracks and there are 2/3 I like but Magna Carter really is ass.

AG
LIG
KD2
KD
4:44
Nasir
BP3




Magna Carter.

And I am typically a Jay Stan.

 

[Bmezy]

Jay..

AG
4:44
KD
KD2

 

[Absolut da poet ®]

Edit ... Jay-Z

AG
BP3
4:44


Magna

 

[Metal Face]

All mid but I guess Jay since he had better beats.

 

[Bigblackted4]

BP3 is not a bad project y’all tripping.

 

[DrexlersFade]

NAS

AND IF WE KEEPIN IT A BUCK, JAY HAD THAT PROJECT WITH BEYONCE (WHACK) AND THE ONE WIT JAY ELECTRONICA (SOLID), SO U CAN REPLACE AMERICAN GANGSTER AND BP3 WIT THOSE

See what they did there Camel stans think they slick

 

[Absolut da poet ®]

BP3 is not a bad project y’all tripping.

I went back and looked at it and realized I liked it way more then KD2 (of which i only like about 4 tracks)

Thank You
Real as it gets
So Ambitious
Already Home
Star is Born
Empire State is Mind
Run this town
What we talking about
DoA
On to the next one

Guess I forgot how good this album really was

 

[Alexander Wiggin]

bump

 

[BigTyme Records]

AG >>> the rest

 

[MJ Truth]

American Gangster is better than Kings Disrase & Nasir

Not better than Life Is Good though.

 

[Cuban Pete]

The highs on BP3 and MCHG were both better than the highs on Nasir. And AG is the best album on the entire list imo

Toss up but I'm still leaning Nas

 

[Kliq_Souf]

1 KD2
2 Life is Good
3. AG
4 4:44
5 KD
6 Nasir
7 BP3
8 Holy Trash

 

[B. Pumpaveli]

Jay got 2 dope albums, AG and 4:44. Blueprint 3 was trash and so was MCHG

Nas got 3 dope albums. Nasir was good, better than both BP3 and MCHG

I love Jay, but Nas got this topic easily.

Edit 1- I’m guessing we not counting lost tapes 2, which would bump LIG off. Then the debate would be a lot closer

Edit 2- If we count Jays album with Beyonce, then that bumps off AG. Then Nas wins very easily

Nasir was not ‘good’