Tony D'Amato
It's all about the inches
He played 3 of the best defenses in the nfl. 2 in horrible weather.
Darnold is a better player than Drake. Hurts, Goff, Dak, Herbert, Love are also better quarterbacks than Maye.One thing I really hate regardless of the sport is how people try and use post season failures to somehow negate what was done in the regular season.
Did drake maye have a bad post season? Yes
Did Drake Maye have an amazing regular season? Yes
Both things can be simultaneously true.
The post season doesn't equal the regular season and people should be smart enough to know that. Drake Maye finished runner up for MVP and was a 2nd team all pro because he was great during the regular season.
The only QBs better than Drake Maye rn are Mahomes, Lamar, Josh Allen, Stafford and maybe Joe Burrow and I said maybe Joe Burrow because he hasn't done shyt for the past few post seasons. For the 2025 REGULAR SEASON Drake Maye was the 2nd best qb in the league. His post season play doesn't change that![]()
Darnold is a better player than Drake. Hurts, Goff, Dak, Herbert, Love are also better quarterbacks than Maye.

He had a great regular season with not just a last place schedule, it was the easiest schedule in The League. Doesn't change that he still played well, but it contextualizes why he played well. Stafford showed multiple times this year that an elite QB could dice up Seattle (even in a loss). For a fact if Allen, Mahomes, Lamar, Burrow ran into Seattle, they would look more like Stafford did vs Seattle, than Maye.
He's not an elite quarterback. He's an ascending Y2 quarterback with a bright future ahead of him.

People forget Patrick Mahomes 1st superbowl, He was running for his life. Put up 9 points 0TD 2 INTs (With Kelce/ Tyreek hill). It happens, Its on Drake Maye to learn from this and get better. Patriots Need to give him some weapons as well.
![]()
Buccaneers 31-9 Chiefs (Feb 7, 2021) Final Score - ESPN
Game summary of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Kansas City Chiefs NFL game, final score 31-9, from February 7, 2021 on ESPN.www.espn.com
DArnold is not a more “consistent decision maker.” Give him Maye’s arm injury and offensive line and weapons and what are we talking about? Maye played all the best defenses in the NFL this playoffs with his offensive line getting cooked and without a number 1 or 2 WR. He will be fine. People pretending that the sky isn’t the limit are just being full of shyt. The kid had a bad playoffs / the entire offense did. He will get better.Lotta talk this postseason crowned him as if he was already that dude. All I'll say is, as much as the regular season showed his growth as a Y2 quarterback, the playoffs showed just how far he needs to go.
Which isn't an indictment because again he's only played two years. My only issue is how people spoke about him as if he already belongs in the elite category. As much as Darnold throws 50/50 passes, he's simply a more consistent decision maker than Maye is at this stage, and falt out better.
Maye has a bright future. He's not That Guy yet.
He is better than Nix.Nix healthy he’s not playing tonight
I also think he didn’t want to throw into the tight windows of the zone.Campbell at LT was getting worked all night, and honestly most of the playoffs. You could see it wearing on Drake as the rounds went on—his reads sped up and he started anticipating pressure that wasn’t always there. Maye is athletic, but he’s not Lamar or Caleb-level athletic, so he’s not just going to escape everything. On top of that, LG Wilson struggled pretty much the entire postseason too. Hard to believe the Pats made the SB with two rookies on the left side of the OL playing like that.
As for Maye himself, he’s always hunting the big play. He’s got to learn to take the checkdown and keep the chains moving. There were multiple 3rd downs where guys were open underneath for a first, and his eyes stayed downfield. It reminds me of early-career Peyton in the playoffs, when the Pats would take away the deep stuff and the Colts’ offense would stall (not saying Drake is Peyton). Once Peyton learned to live with checkdowns, he started beating the Pats. Brady built a GOAT career off taking what the defense gave him. That’s a step Maye still needs to take.
I also think he didn’t want to throw into the tight windows of the zone.
Drake May may not be as good as the media says he is but let's not act like Seattle hasn't been putting most teams in a blender all season. Dude made the SB in year two. If he can continue to learn and improve he will be a very good QB. Also he has rookie tackles starting.
People forget Patrick Mahomes 1st superbowl, He was running for his life. Put up 9 points 0TD 2 INTs (With Kelce/ Tyreek hill). It happens, Its on Drake Maye to learn from this and get better. Patriots Need to give him some weapons as well.
![]()
Buccaneers 31-9 Chiefs (Feb 7, 2021) Final Score - ESPN
Game summary of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers vs. Kansas City Chiefs NFL game, final score 31-9, from February 7, 2021 on ESPN.www.espn.com
