“Rap doesn’t influence anyone to commit crimes”

Do you believe rap influences the youth to commit crimes?

  • Yes

    Votes: 143 74.9%
  • No

    Votes: 48 25.1%

  • Total voters
    191

Kendom

Pro
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
503
Reputation
156
Daps
1,405
You are correct but your stats compared to this thread leaves out an important context. That's the problem with gangs and crack during the 80s and 90s. You also make a good point which is correct about whites being the biggest consumers. However, white kids are not saying they relate to it like blacks nor are they saying rap is a product of their environment. I said this several times in this thread. Rap isn't the sole source of black violence but it does play a role. Name another genre of music where artists are getting killed at the same rate as rappers? Also name another genre of music where artists go to different cities to perform and run into conflict with locals. Please answer cause I'm curious.
Problems with guns and crack? So we don't have problems with gangs and drugs in 2022? Huh?
Whats the relevance of saying they "relate to it?" are you trying to suggest that blacks are more easily impressionable than white kids? if music is such an important cause of crime then it would reflect amongst whites. The only way someone would relate to something is if it reflects something they've witnessed or experienced which goes back to the original point which is that the music is a mirror to the streets

Whatever role rap play is utterly negligible, even if you can name some outlier case it's an outlier you don't base policies on outliers, rappers who die and get into conflict die and get into conflict because they come from and continue to be affiliated with street beef and violent conflicts just like back in their home. People like King Von and FBG Duck. I'm hard pressed to find a rapper that died that wasn't involved in street beef.

As for fights rock and roll stars got into fights all the time. Here's a selection for you

 

kevm3

follower of Jesus
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
16,314
Reputation
5,595
Daps
83,642
Exactly, this dialogue is hella interesting seeing the different perspectives and arguments made.

You even got nikkas doing "Scam Rap". Im sure that influenced hella nikkas to scam.

You also have the lifestyle that's being sold. These kids want the benz, the hoes, the clout, the respect, etc. And then they see and hear what the rapper is rapping about and want to emulate. "If I do XYZ then I can be like "insert rapper name here".

Literally this is how marketing works, and for people to just gloss over the marketing field, clearly are just doing it because they are stuck on their point or just don't want to understand.

Also, some of us actually agree with each other and are just arguing just to argue or not interpreting the points accurately.

I think a lot of people just enjoy their particular artform so much, they don't want to call it for what it is. I enjoy rap music, but I can only listen to it in small doses and I have to be careful about what I listen to, because a lot of it is filled with death and destruction.

A lot of these kids can barely read or remember anything taught in school, but they can recite rap lyrics word for word. Some of these kids use up all of their little summer job money to get a gucci belt to look just like their favorite rapper. Schools are literally bringing rappers into schools.

Now it would be dishonest to say that rap is the SOLE cause of violence in the black community or to say that violence will disappear if we got rid of violence in rap music... but we have to be honest that it DOES influence a lot of kids to engage in deviant behavior because they are trying to emulate what they are seeing on tv. If you do research on how the blood and crips spread in a lot of these cities, sure there was some OG went over there and started the set, but there were a lot who watched Colors and seen the gangsta rap videos of the day and wanted to emulate that.

The reality is that rappers are ultra influential because this is the music of the youth and record labels are draping these kids in white brands to essentially give free marketing to those brands who I'm sure they've cut a deal with in the background. Why do this? Because they know people are going to try to emulate the look. The fact that songs were literally banned from being played in the club because a fight would ALWAYS break out when that song was played shows you the power of music.
 

GPBear

The Tape Crusader
Joined
Mar 9, 2015
Messages
20,114
Reputation
4,770
Daps
67,438
Reppin
Bay-to-PDX
Do you lack all sense of boundaries whatsoever? What the fukk made you think a wm's opinion was necessary itt? Like, tf?



I thought the comparison was apt: @GPBear's kinfolk getting rich off encouraging crash dummy type behavior marketed to us and our children as acceptable.

A lot of y'all being disingenuous in here, btw, and I generally fw yall. Do you not see that we're being socially engineered to self destruct?
Yes.
 

murksiderock

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
15,759
Reputation
6,926
Daps
48,830
Reppin
SMF and LAX to VA and NC
You frame that response as if Wayne and Future are the cause of promethzime being popular. Do you think people would not be sipping lean if not for Wayne and Future?

Let me tell you about the first time I had lean. My partna momma from Houston came up and brought him a big ass jug of lean. He told us that it was some Texas shyt and he poured up and we all was sipping that shyt for a few days. He also told me they did some shyt called handle bars which later I found out was the same thing as zanex. I remember asking him what do they do and he said in Houston we call them mind erasers. I said nikka hell naw, why the fukk would y’all do some shyt like that.

Point is, nikkas was gon be popping pills and sipping lean without rap. And y’all continually and repeatedly place a disproportionate amount of blame on black issues on rap music. And y’all need to cut it out

Again, y’all keep doing this shyt where y’all flat out lie to frame an argument. Nobody is saying that. People are arguing how much influence it has in relation to black crime. People like myself say rap is nowhere near a leading factor, not a root cause, and what is the obsession with singling out and focusing solely on rap music with this board? Other people are acting as if rap music is all that’s wrong with the community. No is pushing back at someone saying rap can be a negative influence, the push back is in y’all having tunnel vision and being obsessed with rap

The first time I had lean was in early 2006, I was 16 and my boy who was like 19 or so, had me over and had a full milk crate with bottles of the shyt. Told me what it was, said nikkas be going crazy over it down south...

I'd heard of it of course, but had never seen it, and didn't personally know anyone who sold it or even spoke of it. So for me personally, I heard of it and it was one ear abd out the other, it wasn't around me...

But when I took the bottles to school, I marketed it as the shyt the rappers were on, I had to because no one around was on that shyt at the time. Muhfukkas were compelled to try it because I said it was cool...

I went up 3-4 months later abd while I was gone in the late 00s is when syrup went completely national. It was still very, very much a deep south drug as late as 2005-2006. This isn't to say "no one" elsewhere ever had access to it, but it certainly wasn't mainstream. Drugs sell themselves but lean specifically, Rose I'm popularity as it was marketed thru hip hop. It didn't spread nationally on some grassroots shyt, I think you would know this, fam...

Also, don't lock into doing the same thing you're accusing others of. I haven't read every post in this thread, but did someone actually say that cats wouldn't be doing drugs if it weren't for hip hop? Don't create ghost arguments that aren't there; I think most people aren't dumb enough to think drug usage started in the hip hop era...

Personally I think the impasse in this debate is with people who feel like rap is being blamed for the ills within black culture, and people who are pointing out that contemporary, popular rap is the primary image of black culture abd it effects us culturally in a number of ways...

The effects of rap aren't all negative but the loudest, most repeated, most widespread forms of it aren't positive and have historical precedent in how we've been marketed in this country. I really hate that so many of us don't get that THAT'S the root of so many of our issue with the music. It really isn't so much about crime, we know violent crime and drugs was here before hip hop...

I love when y'all bring up "before rap music existed", because it tells me that y'all have little to no understanding of past history.

Before rap music existed they used other forms of media propaganda to demonize the image of blacks.

Minstrel Shows, racist cartoons & magazines, movies like "The Birth Of A Nation, etc.

Rap music is a modern day Minstrel Show.

If you had any knowledge of past history there's no way that you would disagree with what I'm saying.

Rap music is literally the modern day Minstrel Show.

Media propaganda such as the negative imagery displayed in rap music also makes BLACK PEOPLE think black people are dangerous and undesirable.

It's absolutely insane to me that black people can't understand the ramifications of constantly having the most negative stereotypes of themselves broadcast to the world.

No other group of men would be proud or allow the main imagery of themselves that's shown to the world to be thugs, gangbangers and drugdealers.

Boy you spitting in these posts...

Do you lack all sense of boundaries whatsoever? What the fukk made you think a wm's opinion was necessary itt? Like, tf?



I thought the comparison was apt: @GPBear's kinfolk getting rich off encouraging crash dummy type behavior marketed to us and our children as acceptable.

A lot of y'all being disingenuous in here, btw, and I generally fw yall. Do you not see that we're being socially engineered to self destruct?

Sis I generally fukk with everybody too but this thread is evidence, for those who need it, of ignorance being bliss. Because the clear answer to your question is no, muhfukkas do not see the engineering of black culture being steered purposefully in one direction, rather than the other...

And it's sad because it's not even just on here, we know of black friends and family offline who are the same way. Too many of us do not have an issue with how we are publicly portrayed and too many of us either don't know and don't want to know, or know and don't care, that modern, popular hip hop is just a continuation of centuries-long framing of who we are to nonblacks...

I generally don't have an issue with nonblack posters but you know this thread mimics life for them too---->white people have no boundaries in reality. They just don't, so of course white boy thinks this conversation needed his two cent, thats white tradition. Good look on calling that shyt out...
 

Tair

American Freedman
Joined
Nov 29, 2019
Messages
7,368
Reputation
3,193
Daps
37,029
Reppin
USA
Do you lack all sense of boundaries whatsoever? What the fukk made you think a wm's opinion was necessary itt? Like, tf?



I thought the comparison was apt: @GPBear's kinfolk getting rich off encouraging crash dummy type behavior marketed to us and our children as acceptable.

A lot of y'all being disingenuous in here, btw, and I generally fw yall. Do you not see that we're being socially engineered to self destruct?

You have a point with certain elements of rap being used to socially engineer or push a narrative but that is not the point of this topic.

OP has a white culture vulture in his avi who constantly promotes hedonism and drugs, yet stays in here dapping up posts disparaging certain rap acts for doing the same thing.
I bet he didn't say a damn thing to Post Malone about the negativity of his music, instead he asked for a picture.

Black Americans know that rap, specifically gangster rap and drill is an outgrowth of those specific rappers lived realities.

We cannot dissociate this system from creating those environments where violent rap grew out of.

These whites and their bootlicks playing chess with y'all. Got folks agreeing that Black folk are the cause of our own problems. They are in here pushing tired crime stats, etc..., and trying to create false narratives and draw baseless conclusions. It's just sloppy and a desperate attempt to shytpost about Black people.

I ain't falling for the bullshyt.

:manny:
 

3rdWorld

Veteran
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
46,689
Reputation
4,326
Daps
136,819
Only white record execs and white fans can say that dumb shyt as hiphops negativity doesn't affect themoet affect them like for Black people.
 

Tair

American Freedman
Joined
Nov 29, 2019
Messages
7,368
Reputation
3,193
Daps
37,029
Reppin
USA
Only white record execs and white fans can say that dumb shyt as hiphops negativity doesn't affect themoet affect them like for Black people.

:stopitslime:









The above is the reason for a lot of crime in the Black community.

Rap does not compare to the nonsense white folks pull everyday to undermine Black progress.


Also read:
"Color of Money" by Mehrsa Baradaran
"Color of Law" by Richard Rothstein
"The Wages of Whiteness" by David Roediger

I already posted a few links in this thread showing crime rates dropping yet knuckleheads keep entering giving their wrong and outdated opinions.

Some of y'all are clearly not Black American.
:snoop:
 
Last edited:

eastside313

Superstar
Joined
May 18, 2012
Messages
18,727
Reputation
1,162
Daps
37,639
Media propaganda such as the negative imagery displayed in rap music also makes BLACK PEOPLE think black people are dangerous and undesirable.

It's absolutely insane to me that black people can't understand the ramifications of constantly having the most negative stereotypes of themselves broadcast to the world.

No other group of men would be proud or allow the main imagery of themselves that's shown to the world to be thugs, gangbangers and drugdealers.
So you didn’t answer my question. You reazlied how ridiculous your statement was. White people been formed they opinions about us. If you think music has anything to do with that you wildin.

Black people don’t need no damn music to tell them nothin about other black people. We live with black folks and we are black folks. What the hell can music or the media tell me unless I’m somewhere around all white people and don’t have no connection to black communities
 
Joined
Aug 10, 2015
Messages
13,742
Reputation
2,315
Daps
65,139
There has been people that have done crime / sold drugs and murder simply because of rap, just like people have taken drugs and shyt because of rock. And people who’ve done crime because of movies. That dude Young Berg admitted to this. So it’s facts.

The real question is; Is it the artist problem? And I say, no; it isn’t. Either raise your child right, or simply don’t have one.

But for any artist lying to themselves that their music isn’t influencing the youth, they’re liars and can’t handle the fact they’ve contributed to violence.
 

3rdWorld

Veteran
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
46,689
Reputation
4,326
Daps
136,819
You cant say music uplift's and inspire's when its all good, but when it comes to rap and negativity claim it doesnt..

You have to take a hard look at the people defending this trite, and ask yourself what their stake is in the conitinued promotion of toxic bullshyt geared to Black youth.

Anyone saying rap has no influence is lying..
 

Double Burger With Cheese

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
27,005
Reputation
16,789
Daps
159,393
Reppin
Atlanta
@Double Burger With Cheese

Do you have an opinion on how black people in America are portrayed in the mainstream? Mainstream meaning, how we are portrayed in all the outlets that reach the masses of the population regardless of where they live...

To your last post you quoted me on: How am creating ghost arguments. I was asking Fat Matt a question because he was insinuating such a thing. He didn’t respond cause dude silly as fukk. Like y’all can act obtuse and skip over every single point I make when asking what are the leading causes of black plight, and how about we focus on them? The point is, rappers the easiest target for these fake intellectual ass nikkas, and thread after thread day after day about what’s wrong with the black community, rappers are at the forefront. And it’s completely disingenuous. I don’t give a fukk about having an unpopular opinion on this board.

I gave that antitode and many others as an example of somebody who learns and develop my opinions about society off personal experience. All the dumb shyt they wanna blame rap for, I was doing without the influence of rap lol.

See I’ve conceded many times that rap can and does have influence. These nikkas will not concede that they are picking low hanging fruit and focusing solely on rap music when the problems they frustrated with much deeper than rap. But they like to latch on to these points for dear life. Ok rap has negative influence, now what? These nikkas not gonna do nothing but make thread after thread and try to make rappers the boogeyman of society, then shame you for listening to rap, then go get in the car and put on Jadakiss. I don’t take these nikkas or this rhetoric serious no matter how many words nikkas type on it.




Now to this post: Do you have an opinion on how black people in America are portrayed in the mainstream?

Nope not really. I have an awareness, just like I have an awareness of my history and everything else going on. But I don’t have an opining strong enough to where I’m about to make thread after thread on a damn Internet forum all day cherry picking hip hop. Hip hop not the problem. Eliminate hip hop and all black people ills still present. Why don’t y’all make thread after thread about that.
 

Kendom

Pro
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
503
Reputation
156
Daps
1,405
1. Post your source of your claim of black crime trending downward

2. I just googled hella articles/stats saying otherwise. Including homicide is #1 killer of black males

3. I dont trust stats
So you ask him to post a source for his claim and then claim you don't trust stats. What would be the point then?:laff:. At least you made it clear that you were arguing in bad faith
 

Double Burger With Cheese

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
27,005
Reputation
16,789
Daps
159,393
Reppin
Atlanta
@Double Burger With Cheese

Do you have an opinion on how black people in America are portrayed in the mainstream? Mainstream meaning, how we are portrayed in all the outlets that reach the masses of the population regardless of where they live...

And another thing. Look at the thread title of the thread and it had a poll:

Do you believe rap influences the youth to commit crimes?​


Of course they can. But that is such a generic question. How is this not a invitation to a circle jerk of nikkas that just wanna shyt on rappers to get they rocks off. What is this doing for the community they care about so much? Not to say you can’t have these conversations. But how is this the only conversation being had…NON MOTHAfukkING STOP. These nikkas not concerned about the community. They concerned with trying to sound smart. I’m actually in the field. A lil nikka pulled a pistol on me like two months ago cause he getting frustrated with me telling him how DUMB the streets is. I wish a nikka would call cap too cause I can actually pull up the audio from my ring camera telling the nikka he ain’t gon do shyt and he not a killer. Couldn’t show the video. But the point is, I truly can’t take these nikkas serious. nikkas not pulling guns out on them for them trying to steer the youth right lol. They on the internet looking for YouTube videos that co-sign they points
 
Top