Archangel

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
8,992
Reputation
2,746
Daps
39,681
I was shocked to learn that Mary J didn't get her 1st number 1 hit until Family Affair in 2001; almost a decade into her career. Its shocking that all her bangers from the 90's never reached number 1.
 

Archangel

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
8,992
Reputation
2,746
Daps
39,681
I agree but it thought we were considering other things besides vocals too
We are but vocals take precedent over everything else. If not someone like Mary would be a 10 because her catalog of music shyts on everyone else's on that list. So while I know nikkas are being influenced by nostalgia and their bias, I have no real quarrels with the list so far. Well I would move Anita down a bit but it's pretty accurate in my opinion.
 

BmoreGorilla

Veteran
Joined
Sep 17, 2014
Messages
39,592
Reputation
33,659
Daps
256,692
Reppin
Man, woman, and child
We are but vocals take precedent over everything else. If not someone like Mary would be a 10 because her catalog of music shyts on everyone else's on that list. So while I know nikkas are being influenced by nostalgia and their bias, I have no real quarrels with the list so far. Well I would move Anita down a bit but it's pretty accurate in my opinion.
I get it which is why I initially had Mary at 8. Of course she ain’t the best vocalist but she’s an icon becuz she hits on everything else
 

Archangel

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
8,992
Reputation
2,746
Daps
39,681
I get it which is why I initially had Mary at 8. Of course she ain’t the best vocalist but she’s an icon becuz she hits on everything else
I get you. But Marys vocals are very not good bro. You can argue she's the worse singer on the list so far. Her other accolades don't pump her up that much. I think I voted her a 6 so a 7.10 is generous for her.
 

#1 pick

The Smart Negroes
Supporter
Joined
Jul 13, 2012
Messages
78,776
Reputation
11,784
Daps
203,029
Reppin
Lamb of God
I get you. But Marys vocals are very not good bro. You can argue she's the worse singer on the list so far. Her other accolades don't pump her up that much. I think I voted her a 6 so a 7.10 is generous for her.
No the fukk she's not you idiot. Half the list is pop artists. You about to join that nikka that gave A. BAKER a 1 in the negged for stupidity list
 
Joined
Aug 3, 2012
Messages
46,130
Reputation
-34,976
Daps
251,387
We are but vocals take precedent over everything else. If not someone like Mary would be a 10 because her catalog of music shyts on everyone else's on that list. So while I know nikkas are being influenced by nostalgia and their bias, I have no real quarrels with the list so far. Well I would move Anita down a bit but it's pretty accurate in my opinion.


I get vocals are the highest priority, but even with that and taking everything else into account H.E.R shouldn’t be higher than Mary j Blige or have the same score as Beyoncé. She hasn’t even dropped an album and her biggest single is a feature with Daniel ceaser. She doesn’t have albums, Tours or live examples to be in that playing field.

:hhh:
 

Archangel

Banned
Joined
May 10, 2015
Messages
8,992
Reputation
2,746
Daps
39,681
I get vocals are the highest priority, but even with that and taking everything else into account H.E.R shouldn’t be higher than Mary j Blige or have the same score as Beyoncé. She hasn’t even dropped an album and her biggest single is a feature with Daniel ceaser. She doesn’t have albums, Tours or live examples to be in that playing field.

:hhh:
The coli hates Beyonce and has a crush on HER cause she's new blood bringing back that old feeling in music. Prisoners of the moment.

I agree with you brah all things considered. I'm just tryna shed light on how I think most voters think when talking about Mary J.
 
Top