Rate This Singer - Leaderboard (Females)

[Secure Da Bag]

I am eager to see where Badu lands

It's gonna be under Jill Scott. Believe that.

 

[Secure Da Bag]

Yes sir. I would appreciate it if you would not challenge my decision and hurt my feelings. Beyonce is boring to me - soulless. Aaliyah exudes personality, style , class, street music vibe .. all that,

But you're comparing them as artist not as singers or vocalists. If you were comparing Beyonce to Aaliyah when Aaliyah was alive, then Aaliyah all day. But Beyonce's range has improved since then.

 

[Nicole0416_718_929_646212]

But you're comparing them as artist not as singers or vocalists. If you were comparing Beyonce to Aaliyah when Aaliyah was alive, then Aaliyah all day. But Beyonce's range has improved since then.

Aaliyah didn’t have a fair chance to hone her craft, even if she didn’t Aaliyah’s musical style, dance ability,originality and vocals on that level are better than Beyonce’s on a good day. I’m not trying to hear it. I could copy and paste Beyoncé’s performance and videos from one to another and nothing would change - looks your same, sounds the same, same dances...

 

[Secure Da Bag]

Aaliyah didn’t have a fair chance to hone her craft, even if she didn’t Aaliyah’s musical style, dance ability,originality and vocals on that level are better than Beyonce’s on a good day. I’m not trying to hear it. I could copy and paste Beyoncé’s performance and videos from one to another and nothing would change - looks your same, sounds the same, same dances...

Wut? Aaliyah was at the top of her game and was transitioning to acting. She had already killed the music game. She was on top. I already said Beyonce wasn't seeing her at that time in any category. But Beyonce's vocal game has improved greatly since her debut. It's unfair to compare the two since Aaliyah past so early. But Beyonce is better vocally as of right now.

 

[™BlackPearl The Empress™]

It's gonna be under Jill Scott. Believe that.

 

[Nicole0416_718_929_646212]

Wut? Aaliyah was at the top of her game and was transitioning to acting. She had already killed the music game. She was on top. I already said Beyonce wasn't seeing her at that time in any category. But Beyonce's vocal game has improved greatly since her debut. It's unfair to compare the two since Aaliyah past so early. But Beyonce is better vocally as of right now.

I like you, you know this, but your opinion on this is basura. Beyoncé is very overrated bc of the push that she gets. I’m putting it to you like this - I’m more of a rap fan, fam so whatever R&B that I listen to has to be top tier and I really have to be feeling a song. With the exception of her song ,” Diva” (because it used to be my motivation music ) Beyoncé is not on my playlists - I have Spotify, google play and YouTube - she’s not seeing any of that . Mariah gets more plays than Beyoncé, so she and her chancleta wearing camel can hit the road

 

[Secure Da Bag]

Beyoncé is very overrated bc of the push that she gets. I’m putting it to you like this - I’m more of a rap fan, fam so whatever R&B that I listen to has to be top tier and I really have to be feeling a song. With the exception of her song ,” Diva” (because it used to be my motivation music ) Beyoncé is not on my playlists - I have Spotify, google play and YouTube - she’s not seeing any of that . Mariah gets more plays than Beyoncé, so she and her chancleta wearing camel can hit the road

Brought to you by Nasir Dash Productions.

Spoiler

Don't think I don't know you a Nas stan and decided to throw shots at Jay while you're at it

 

[MajesticLion]

What's the criteria for this?

Because Shirley Bassey, Ella Fitzgerald, Aretha Franklin, Celia Cruz, hell even Christina Aguilera all have better pipes than half of that list.

 

[Nicole0416_718_929_646212]

Brought to you by Nasir Dash Productions.

Spoiler

Don't think I don't know you a Nas stan and decided to throw shots at Jay while you're at it

My opinion is not biased , I am simply stating my views.

 

[Standing on business]

But you're comparing them as artist not as singers or vocalists. If you were comparing Beyonce to Aaliyah when Aaliyah was alive, then Aaliyah all day. But Beyonce's range has improved since then.

When they were both alive Beyonce was the way better singer, it’s never been close.

 

[Standing on business]

I like you, you know this, but your opinion on this is basura. Beyoncé is very overrated bc of the push that she gets. I’m putting it to you like this - I’m more of a rap fan, fam so whatever R&B that I listen to has to be top tier and I really have to be feeling a song. With the exception of her song ,” Diva” (because it used to be my motivation music ) Beyoncé is not on my playlists - I have Spotify, google play and YouTube - she’s not seeing any of that . Mariah gets more plays than Beyoncé, so she and her chancleta wearing camel can hit the road

You can not like Beyoncé that’s cool, but you should never ever throw rocks at the thrown, at the goat, jigga held you Down 23 summers damn

 

[Secure Da Bag]

When they were both alive Beyonce was the way better singer, it’s never been close.

 

[Nicole0416_718_929_646212]

You can not like Beyoncé that’s cool, but you should never ever throw rocks at the thrown, at the goat, jigga held you Down 23 summers damn

Never liked him and never vibed with his music ... Jigga who??

 

[Archangel]

What's the criteria for this?

Because Shirley Bassey, Ella Fitzgerald, Aretha Franklin, Celia Cruz, hell even Christina Aguilera all have better pipes than half of that list.

Check the criteria in one of the threads, it's listed at the top. If you'd like to, I can add you to the tag list so you can join in our discussions.

 

[Archangel]

My opinion is not biased , I am simply stating my views.

Nicole, you the homie but you gotta chill on this Aaliyah vs Bey debate. At no time in her life was Aaliyah ever a better vocalist than Beyonce. A better artist? Absolutely. Better music? Absolutely. Singing though?