Rogue One is by far the best Star Wars movie.

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

But because the others made more money, and the fact that not enough people supported it, we didn’t get more Star Wars movies like this.

and because the OG characters were so iconic, recasting them for an entire reboot, starting with episode 4 was completely out of the question.

 

[Standing on business]

A new hope >


Rogue one is easily the best modern Star Wars movie though

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Overrated

 

[Bryan Danielson]

I dont necessarily think any of the Star Wars are terrible or bad with the exception of Ep 1.

But I do think yall expectations were way tooooooooo high and they never had a chance

 

[KidJSoul]

No, its easily Empire Strikes Back. Its the only truly great movie in the franchise

A New Hope is good

The rest range from mediocre to bad

 

[Paper Boi]

Empire Strikes Back


also ROTS would have been up there if Hayden Christensen wasn't such a trash actor.

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

A new hope >


Rogue one is easily the best modern Star Wars movie though

modern being the key word. The music, VFX and writing was better. There was more detail and the characters were better fleshed out that when they all died you felt for them more.

when padme died, I didn’t give a shyt. Both her and anikin were annoying and they had no chemistry. the only thing the OG movies got on rogue one is nostalgia.

I would rather get a sequel to rogue one on the form of clone wars than a new era of Star Wars. Darth Vader is their most iconic character but they barely use him.

 

[Deltron]

Best SW flick Disney will ever make

K2's sacrifice > bytch ass 3PO's in RoS

 

[old pig]

Overrated

agreed...rep cuz it’s not a very popular opinion to state at all

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

Everyone in here shytting on this movie, is the reason why TFA was a different version of a new hope and why the other movies in the sequel were safe cookie cutter for the masses type movies.

all they had to do was make epic trailers and you all with give them money.

 

[Real]

easily the most cohesive star wars movie

 

[wtfyomom]

its 3rd best behind new hope and empire strikes back

 

[Days of Future Piff]

Sorry, but I can't agree...

Episodes III, IV, V, and VI >>>>>>>>>

Rogue One had some dope action scenes near the end, but there wasn't a single memorable character in the movie (not counting cameos from the OG's from the original films).
When I left the theater after seeing it, I didn't remember a single one of the main character's names.
Nobody on that crew had a character arc as heroic as Luke. None of them had Han Solo's swag. None of them were as endearing as the droids.

No Star Wars movie in existence is topping A New Hope, or The Empire Strikes Back.
(Return of the Jedi also gets a pass on the strength of the the throne room showdown and Vader's redemption at the end.)

Episode III is better than any Disney Star Wars movie. It's overrated and it's flawed, but it still gave us the clone wars and a more compelling character arc than anything we got from the cardboard cutout characters in Rogue One. The crappy dialogue and excessive CG held RotS back, but the overall concept of Palpatine tempting Anakin to join the Dark Side is still solid. Dope concept, flawed execution.

I'll put Rogue one over the Last Jedi and Rise of Skywalker though.

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

its 3rd best behind new hope and empire strikes back

The first two are nostalgic. That don't make them better movies :mipls: it was too campy.

That's like saying Goonies is better than Stranger Things.

Some OG movies hold up better than the sequel made decades later and some dont

 

[Ethnic Vagina Finder]

Sorry, but I can't agree...

Episodes III, IV, V, and VI >>>>>>>>>

Rogue One had some dope action scenes near the end, but there wasn't a single memorable character in the movie (not counting cameos from the OG's from the original films).
When I left the theater after seeing it, I didn't remember a single one of the main character's names.
Nobody on that crew had a character arc as heroic as Luke. None of them had Han Solo's swag. None of them were as endearing as the droids.

No Star Wars movie in existence is topping A New Hope, or The Empire Strikes Back.
(Return of the Jedi also gets a pass on the strength of the the throne room showdown and Vader's redemption at the end.)

Episode III is better than any Disney Star Wars movie. It's overrated and it's flawed, but it still gave us the clone wars and a more compelling character arc than anything we got from the cardboard cutout characters in Rogue One. The crappy dialogue and excessive CG held RotS back, but the overall concept of Palpatine tempting Anakin to join the Dark Side is still solid. Dope concept, flawed execution.

I'll put Rogue one over the Last Jedi and Rise of Skywalker though.

This is a classic example of people confusing nostalgia for epic or great.

Luke's character arc was basic as hell. He really had not real motivation. Obi wan didnt even tell him who Vader really was and was playing unnecessary games.


Harrison Ford stole the shine from Luke


The droids weren't "endearing" as you're trying to play it



The stakes were way higher in Rogue One. It basically set up the events of new hope.


But to each his own


You and all other fans have proven that you won't rock work star wars unless there are OG characters taking up all the screen time. Its what's held this franchise back honestly.