I did quantify how I am defining "Peak". Please read again. If you want to disagree with my definition, that's fine. If you want to ignore it and present your own definition, that's fine. But I'm not arguing his defensive abilities.
Let me try to summarize as follows: Shaq was the most efficient offensive weapon I've ever seen, and I believe his offensive efficiency and utility exceeds that of other great centers.
PS: Duncan's a PF.
PPS: Duncan never shut down SHaq either.
PPPS: Kobe sucked in 99
Well there is more to the game than offense and how is does his efficiency and utility exceed other centers when other guys scored as many or more points and shot comparable or superior percentages and he was a liablity due to his FT issues?
Never said Duncan shut him down but he gave him that work and led his underdog Spurs to a fukking 4 game sweep over his Lakers. That's some Wilt shyt and I don't mean that in a good way.
You takin Mario Elie or Jaron Jackson over Kobe at that point?





And Hakeem's best isn't better than Shaq's best. ..Shaq would of crushed Kareem. Kareem can't be who he is if played against Shaq...same goes for Wilt and Russell.
and he had a life sized replica of Mike in his backcourt. So what basis is there to believe he would dominate any other era like you and others are suggesting?
