The cf playoffs have been a success

[concise]

How would it have been Alabama vs. FSU? Wasn't Oregon the 2-seed? Wouldn't it have been Alabama vs. Oregon?

FSU was actually ranked #1 in the polls (which used to make up a big chunk of the BCS rankings) for most of the year and never fell below second. It's the committee's playoff rankings that decided to toy with them all year. They would have no doubt been in the title game if the BCS still existed.

 

[CodeBlaMeVi]

Eight teams is too many. Six is enough. No conference should get an auto berth. Record should get you a chance to get a bye. Let four teams battle it out for the scraps in wild card weekend. Then divisional round where 1 meets winner of 3 vs 6 and 2 meets winner of 4 vs 5. Then Championship game to determine the winner. There should be a reward for having a good record in the regular season other than just seeding. Also with six teams there will be one or two 2 loss teams in there most years. With eight teams and five auto qualifiers+ three at large slots you might get some 3 loss team in while some one loss team is out. That would be BS.

This right here I support.

 

[Panther]

I like it at 4 teams. Ive never felt like the 7th and 8th ranked teams this late into a season are deserving to play for a title.

And with bama and FSU losing i think it shows that the right 4 teams made it in, cause no one was talking about TCU being in over bama or FSU a few weeks ago

 

[MikelArteta]

Think about the student-athletes guys. They can't have an extended playoff because that will take precious time away from their studies

 

[MikelArteta]

Every conference deserves a spot, then you could stop with that weakness if schedule weakness of conference ish.

Oh the big ten is weak is it?

 

[hotbeezie]

I say 8 or 16

8

P5 champs
Highest ranked mid-major
2 at large

16

10 conference champs
6 at large

 

[Quarterback]

8-team playoff would be fukking awesome. If CFB could replicate the same insanity that exists in D1 college basketball with underdogs going on miracle runs it would make it a lot more interesting.

No it wouldn't. You need to be dominant all season to even be considered for the Nat Ch. No 2 or 3 loss teams, fukk that.

at nikkas who want students to play more games. They're not pros, nikkas

 

[Ohene]

16 is way too much. 8 teams and you call it a day.

but i'm even fine with 4

 

[L. Deezy]

I like it at 4 teams. Ive never felt like the 7th and 8th ranked teams this late into a season are deserving to play for a title.

And with bama and FSU losing i think it shows that the right 4 teams made it in, cause no one was talking about TCU being in over bama or FSU a few weeks ago

I agree.. 4 is just fine..

 

[The_Sheff]

No it wouldn't. You need to be dominant all season to even be considered for the Nat Ch. No 2 or 3 loss teams, fukk that.

at nikkas who want students to play more games. They're not pros, nikkas

So the students at FCS schools are pros?

 

[Roid Jones]

It will eventually be 8 teams and it damn well should

 

[USSInsiders]

No it wouldn't. You need to be dominant all season to even be considered for the Nat Ch. No 2 or 3 loss teams, fukk that.

at nikkas who want students to play more games. They're not pros, nikkas

Nobody forced these fakkits to play ball. At the end of the day, we're all watching these dudes bash their skulls into each other at high velocity because we love the game(s). I want an 8-team playoff.

 

[USSInsiders]

Eight teams is too many. Six is enough. No conference should get an auto berth. Record should get you a chance to get a bye. Let four teams battle it out for the scraps in wild card weekend. Then divisional round where 1 meets winner of 3 vs 6 and 2 meets winner of 3 v 5. Then Championship game to determine the winner. There should be a reward for having a good record in the regular season other than just seeding. Also with six teams there will be one or two 2 loss teams in there most years. With eight teams and five auto qualifiers+ three at large slots you might get some 3 loss team in while some one loss team is out. That would be BS.

I take it back, 6 would be gucci. 8 is probably a tad too high because then it dilutes regular season games.

 

[Ohene]

I like it at 4 teams. Ive never felt like the 7th and 8th ranked teams this late into a season are deserving to play for a title.

And with bama and FSU losing i think it shows that the right 4 teams made it in, cause no one was talking about TCU being in over bama or FSU a few weeks ago

the only team that can argue they got jerked this year is TCU and to be frank they did.

But OSU took care of Business so you cant be mad. TCU is looking at FSU like but them boys were undefeated so what can you do.

Four teams is perfectly fine.

Michigan State, Ole Piss, Mississippi State, and Baylor

 

[BlackAchilles]

No it wouldn't. You need to be dominant all season to even be considered for the Nat Ch. No 2 or 3 loss teams, fukk that.

at nikkas who want students to play more games. They're not pros, nikkas

"Students"