this argument will never be settled. you will have people on both sides of the fence who wont budge. ultimately, no one will be proven right or wrong. what will happen is...someone will lose credibility as time passes by the actions they take. who will lose the most credibility? (hold on to that for a sec, we will return to that point.)
Q: who is Floyd to ask the
#2 draw to concede to financial demands?
A: the
#1 draw
easy answer and simple mathematics. without fighting Manny, Floyd is still the top paid athlete. No argument can change that.
Q: who needs who more?
A: Manny needs Floyd more
another easy answer. Pac has lost, so its been proven he can be beaten....KOed even. he's lost 5 times and been KOed 3. with the doping allegations and his reluctance to take a test...Manny's legacy is far more in doubt than Floyd's.
Q: Did Manny have a legitimate excuse for not agreeing to tests?
A: No. If you opponent will take the same exact test, there is no legitimate excuse, but lets say there was for the sake of argument...all of that now goes out the window because Pacquiao is now asking Rios to do it, in light of getting KOed by Memo's client JMM who Rio's is now a client of.
Q: Who was King of the Hill post-DLH?
A: Floyd
another easy answer. the thing that matters the most when speaking in terms of leverage is who got to what point first. Floyd beat Oscar first. He was proclaimed P4P first. He has always been the biggest draw post-DLH. Again, I am only dealing with pure fact here, not speculation.
the PPV arguments pre-DLH are subjective as hell when discussing with people who :udontknow: and you cant take them for face value because Pac was fighting Mexican legends because they were in and around his weight class. Floyd had none at Welterweight, except for calling JMM up. 1 fight with JMM doesnt compare with 4 fights with JMM, 3 fights with Morales, and 1 fight with Barerra.
peoples talk about Floyd fighting on Cinco De Mayo and all that but Pac has made his living off of Mexican legends. the only reason the Bradley fight was big because of pre-Floyd fight hype.
my point is this....its never equal, one fighter is bigger than the other. that fighter in this case is Floyd. so you have to look at where the ultimate breakdown is. they both have blame. Floyd may have demanded too much...but the biggest linchpin in the deal was the testing. If Team Pac agrees to that, then that doesnt say that Floyd makes the fight, but it gives him NOWHERE to hide. the ball would effectively be back in his court and if negotiations flop, everyone will say..."Floyd didnt want the fight because his financial demands were too outrageous"
Now, back to the statement I made in the first paragraph. "someone will lose credibility as time passes by the actions they take."
by asking Rios to take tests when he would never completely agree throws all other arguments out the window and makes him look like a complete hypocrite. whether its not wanting to take tests or making a fighter of smaller stature concede to HIS demands. the same arguments made against Floyd.
the big difference is, Floyd "wanted to clean up the sport" as an undefeated fighter. Manny "wants to clean up the sport" after he got KTFOed.