Lots of gems in this thread
Thoughts on the VW Atlas (used)? I've been looking at the 5 series BMW but my '10 Accord still gets the job done and not having a car pymt is
Avoid the first year or two. Lots of teething issues. A lot of dumb shyt happened the first year/year and a half of production (head bolts not being tight from the factory and causing leaking head gaskets for one). If your budget allows, get the VR6 and not the 2.0T. The virtual cockpit is also a nice option to have if buying used, and it's standard on the '22-'23 Atlas. The R-line is primarily an appearance package, and it's highly subjective whether or not you like how it looks, so YMMV. It should be noted that if you decide you want an R-line Atlas, the wheels and tires are larger, but cost more for replacement, just a heads up. Aside from those initial teething issues, it's been relatively reliable for a VW.
In terms of whether or not it's a good buy, it depends -- is this potentially your first VW? The Atlas, for what it replaced, is a better SUV for the US market than the Touareg ever was; it's a lot more space efficient, and cheaper to maintain since it shares parts with the golf, Jetta, Tiguan, Taos, etc. If you're used to Japanese cars and their maintenance costs - any German product is going to be drastically different than your traditional Japanese vehicle. Expect to replace your front brakes on the Atlas every 60-70k under normal driving conditions, rears 40-50k. The VW certified pre-owned warranty has varying terms (some are 1 year 12k miles with a $50 deductible, some are 2/24k with a $50 deductible). Coolant exchange at 100k. Transfer case fluid should be changed every 3 years regardless of mileage, no exceptions. (This is assuming the Atlas you're looking at has 4 motion). Spark Plugs and transmission fluid are every 80k miles. If you need more detailed information, ask away.