*Updated* 15 finalists were named for the Pro Football HOF. Who you letting in?

Fred Taylor should've gotten in years ago.

 

Why is drew pearson in the HOF....I swear I hate cowboy bias. Did dude ever lead the league in anything at any point in time in his career????

 

Nah, if the HOF has a few kickers and punters in it, there's room for a return man also.

 

If Hester wore a metallic silver helmet with a "flying Elvis" on it , I'm sure this opinion would be different.

 

H-o-l-t is banned because of that weird-ass troll that used to be in TLR that would catfish for dikk pics.

And you need not make ANY references to "a certain former Colts WR who may or may not have worn #88".

Sidenote: Forget that I have said anything on this matter.

Don't want no problems for mentioning "#88"

 

A kicker and punter have a bigger impact on the game than a returner. And, Guy played decades ago.

Not to mention the kickers and punters have longer careers and more impact. Hester was a great returner, but I don't think there is any way he should get in..

 

Shout out to the U

 

Not necessarily and not for any given punter or kicker. Hester had teams scared and would change the way they would change the way they would kick off and punt. Heck, even Terrence McGee on the Bills had Belichick scared of him to the point where he would rather kick the kickoff out of bounds than have it go to McGee back in 2004 in the game at Buffalo. And McGee wasn't on Hester's level.

Still, with that said, I wouldn't put Hester in above some of the other candidates that are still eligible.

 

I agree he shouldn't have gotten it either. I was very disappointed when he got in and it made it seem like some of the other running backs are getting then too.

 

Lol@Hester not being in. Special teams is 33% of the game and he dominated that phase on a transcendent level.

 

Hester should not get in and won't get in. We get it, he went to The U.

Special teams is NOT 33% of the game no matter how you want to phrase it.. It's important, but not every phase of football is equal, and a returner sure as hell isn't THAT valuable..

 

Boselli, Pat Willis, Bryant Young, Steve Smith, and Ronde

 

Ok casual

Hester will be in the HOF eventually and there's nothing you can do about it

 

Steve Smith easy.