Who was better? Paul Pierce or Carmelo Anthony

[Greenhornet]

Pierce doesnt get enough credit for literally sticking with Boston and always being ready until his very last season

and this is coming from someone who isnt too high on Boston

The Antoine Walker days were crazy

 

[ogc163]

Pierce actually played defense.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Put prime melo on those Celtics teams and they win 2 or 3 titles.

This is nonsense. They had the best record in the league the following year and then KG got hurt. The Celts were never the same after KG's injury because KG was never the same.

Nonetheless Pierce and Allen played very well in the playoffs and Pierce still had a lot of playoff moments like when they took the Heat to 7 games when they were all by that point..

Melo didn't do anything close.. This is Pierce easy and the poll backs it up.

 

[Chris Cool]

Melo best teammate was Chauncy. Pierce legacy changed once he got Ray and Kevin.

 

[MoneyTron]

I’d probably go with Pierce because of his ballhandling skills and defensive advantage over Melo.

Melo definitely the better scorer without a doubt though but prime Paul was no slouch.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Melo best teammate was Chauncy. Pierce legacy changed once he got Ray and Kevin.

Thank you! Him and Toine was shimmying out the first round or missing the playoffs completely with a miracle run in the mix. Doc, KG, Rondo and Ray got him over

 

[AlbertPullhoez]

Melo was better

Melo was 2 wins away vs Kobe/Pau/LO (which Denver could've got if they knew how to inbound the damn ball) from going to the Finals

Dude turned the Nuggets from a 17 win team the previous season to a playoff squad his rookie year

Hell the best season the clusterfukk known as the Knicks have had in forever was cause of Melo.

He got about 4 seasons better than Pierce's best season. While playing in a much tougher conference at that

shyt Melo was better as a freshman at Syracuse than Pierce was in 3 years at Kansas

 

[Ziggiy]

My heart says Melo my Mind says Pierce

 

[Ziggiy]

Thank you! Him and Toine was shimmying out the first round or missing the playoffs completely with a miracle run in the mix. Doc, KG, Rondo and Ray got him over

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Thank you! Him and Toine was shimmying out the first round or missing the playoffs completely with a miracle run in the mix. Doc, KG, Rondo and Ray got him over

nikka they made it to the eastern conference finals with a bum ass team in 02. The fukk.

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Thank you! Him and Toine was shimmying out the first round or missing the playoffs completely with a miracle run in the mix. Doc, KG, Rondo and Ray got him over

Doc had a minimal role compared to kg and ray

Doc was close to being fired and pierce got himself ejected in a playoff game

Thibs was damn near just as important as doc in that title run

 

[stepbackj34spud]

Melo was better

Melo was 2 wins away vs Kobe/Pau/LO (which Denver could've got if they knew how to inbound the damn ball) from going to the Finals

Dude turned the Nuggets from a 17 win team the previous season to a playoff squad his rookie year

Hell the best season the clusterfukk known as the Knicks have had in forever was cause of Melo.

He got about 4 seasons better than Pierce's best season. While playing in a much tougher conference at that

shyt Melo was better as a freshman at Syracuse than Pierce was in 3 years at Kansas

Melo was never better than Pierce. You are looking at ppg. Having a higher ppg doesn’t not make you better player. Pierce was better than Melo probably until like 2012 or 2013. Smfh

Melo wasn’t a better scorer either, he just took more shots. Sheesh. But the polls speaks for themselves. fukk your opinion this poll lopsided hahaha.

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

nikka they made it to the eastern conference finals with a bum ass team in 02. The fukk.

Once in a decade. I can divide nikka

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Doc had a minimal role compared to kg and ray

Doc was close to being fired and pierce got himself ejected in a playoff game

Thibs was damn near just as important as doc in that title run

Agreed. Forgot Thibs was on that staff

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

Agreed. Forgot Thibs was on that staff

Main thing doc came up with was ubuntu. He was a chemistry manager