Pharell's Blurred Lines Deposition [LEAKED]...EDIT: More parts added #ImNotComfortable

[Gaara]

My point was I believe Marv didnt write or come up w/ the part that was stole, yet his family and nobody elses were able to sue and get guap.

Okay i see your point. But regardless of if he came up with it or not the man with the credit is the man with the power.

The same thing happened with I'll Be Missing You by Puff.

Sting, Puff Daddy, Andy Summers, and the case of the misplaced bajillion dollars

 

[Nigerianwonder]

point blank the family didnt sue him for sampling the record, and they didnt sue him for taking a melody... they sued him for taking a 'feel'... they sued him for creativing something that is evocative of marvin gaye... and while its true that he did... its not illegal to do so...

The problem with your argument is that based on the statements/ interviews made by robin thicke and pharell themselves one could say that without "got to give it up" there would be no "blurred lines". It appears to be a direct correlation based on statements made from them regarding how they came up with blurred lines so credit is due.

 

[Clayton Endicott]

Make original music, or make sure you get that clearance brehs

 

[Arithmetic]

Them lawyers went the fukk in

In.

 

[scuba]

The problem with your argument is that based on the statements/ interviews made by robin thicke and pharell themselves one could say that without "got to give it up" there would be no "blurred lines". It appears to be a direct correlation based on statements made from them regarding how they came up with blurred lines so credit is due.

the point i am making is that the fact there is a direct correlation between the songs doesnt mean its infringement, at least traditionally that wasnt considered infringement.

 

[Hannibal Fox]

Teddy Riley (Self-Taught)

Danja (Self-Taught)

Scott Storch (Trained/Self-Taught)

Darkchild (Trained)

Just Blaze (Self-Taught)

Mike Dean (Trained)

Ryan Leslie (Self-Taught)

Mario Winans (Self-Taught)

London on da Track (Self-Taught)

Zaytoven (Self-Taught)

Organize Noize (Self-Taught)

Drumma Boy (Trained)

Eric Hudson (Self-Taught)

Terrace Martin (Trained)

DJ Quik (Self-Taught)

Warryn Campbell (Self-Taught)

Battlecat (Self-Taught)

Really?

Not being sarcastic here; but I would have thought that coming from such a musical family that he would have at least some modicum of training.

 

[Sauce Dab]

Dude is nervous as fukk, you'd think they charged him with murder

this is how real goats do it

Just can't imagine with hair.

 

[DEAD7]

Dude is nervous as fukk, you'd think they charged him with murder

this is how real goats do it

3:35 that face

Thats my GOAT

 

[Mr. Manhattan]

Steal records brehs

 

[666 ReVeNGe 666]

Looks like Pharell studied Lil Wayne's deposition video before going to his.

Wayne's was classic

 

[Michael's Black Son]

this is also true.

If he admits that he can read the music, then he'll have to cop to in fact, theft.

Shoulda use the Thicke defense. Robin said he was drunk and high the whole time they were recording and doesn't remember shyt

 

[Booker T Garvey]

Damn, this is pretty bad

 

[Michael's Black Son]

Truthfully, the only similarity is stylistically. The music itself isn't the same. The lyrics are completely different, can't own a chord progression (they're slightly different), and different sounds. It's one of the craziest lawsuits I've seen. The closest thing derived from got to give it up are the chants Pharrell did on blurred lines. You all can cook, though. Provide actual evidence that he stole from Marvin Gaye.

This. People will clown him in this thread but the music is different as is the lyrics and melody. The sheet music would easily prove that the chords/notes are different but people hear a fukking cowbell and suddenly they're "guilty".

Notice how other artists didn't co-sign this verdict because even fukking Rae Sremmurd could tell that both songs are different. I find it hard to believe that Pharrell would blatantly plagiarize on a smash hit that the whole world is gonna hear and think that it's all good. And at what point in his career has a precedent of "stealing" been an issue? Never.

Marvin's family rolled the dice on this one and hit a hell of a lick. But how much did they truly care about the legacy of his musical integrity (and not the marketing/licensing bullshyt) before the lawyers rolled up?

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

hes not comfortable bc he doesnt know music theory
theyre trying to expose him and he got exposed. anyone who know the answers to those theory questions would answer it wit the quikness.
and him not being able to answer those questions proves that his opinion about anything theoretical with that song is NULL AND VOID.
he dont wtf hes talking bout. and all hes looking like is a BEAT BITER

Did you not read?

If he admitted it, he'd admit to being able to read music...and thus admitting he stole the song

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

"The Jew lawyer, the true employeer That will destroy ya defense like the Hoyas ." - Jada

Juan Epstein