panopticon
Superstar
Yeah, his height and lack of athleticism is definitely a worry. I can't argue with you on any of your points.I simply believe he lacks the TALENT to be a great NFL player.
He's short and unathletic. That's typically not a good combination is professional sports.
My NFL comp for him is Case Keenum. You give Baker Mayfield a loaded team like Barnum had last year in Minnesota and he can be successful. However, you put him on a bad team without talent and it could get real ugly.
Baker Mayfield is simply not talented enough to raise the level of his team. He's a product of the Oklahoma/Big 12/air raid system IMO.
To be fair, I'm biased here - I'd love to see a bit of a hellraiser at QB. Probably not the smartest thing (the Jets aren't my team ) but as a fan I still want to see it.
A little fukkery at QB for once would be welcome
As far as Josh Allen goes - I'm with you all the way on him. Give him 2-3 years to develop and I think his ceiling is John Elway. Extremely bright, extremely athletic (6 foot 5 running a 4.75 40??? ) and he throws gotdamn ICBMs.
People forget that his first 10 years in the league, Elway almost threw more picks than touchdowns (158 TDs to 157 INTs)
But then he turned into a fukkin monster , and never let up until he retired.