Career wise... Manu>>>>>>>>>>>Melo amirite

[The Connoisseurs]

In a alternate universe Detroit selected Melo and Larry brown is a reasonable coach. Also Melo is recognized as a top 5 dead or Alive

 

[Patrick Kane]

Are you implying that more points per game means someone is a better player than the other?

When someone averages 25 ppg for for a decade and is on pace to score 30,000 points (which is the objective of basketball) YES

Melo is one of the most dynamic and unique scorers in NBA history. Just cause he has a shyt attitude and is completely washed now doesn't mean he wasn't a dominant player in his prime. He wasn't no slouch ever.

 

[NY's #1 Draft Pick]

I consider ginobili a top 10 shooting guard

 

[Shadow King]

Ginobili has 4 rings and led the team that created the need for a Redeem Team. Yes.

 

[Samson]

Melo >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Manu at the bank

 

[Strapped]

You are

 

[nieman]

Ok If Manu > Melo, Sheed > KG, Chuck & Malone

 

[staticshock]

Convinced this board is 93% cacs.

Don’t ever disrespect Melo again by saying Manu better.

 

[Mr Hate Coffee]

I came into this thread thinking t wasn’t even a debate. How is anyone saying Melo had a better career?

 

[DonkeyPuncher718]

I have to be honest if youre asking me if I had to choose between both in their prime im going Manu

Ive seen this man do it all offensively AND defensively with steals and game clinching blocks



Remeber kids this is an 40 YEAR OLD MAN DOING THIS TO ONE OF THE TOP 5 PLAYERS IN THE LEAGUE IN THE PLAYOFFS

Yall going to put some respecto on Ginobili Name and Game

 

[Remote]

When someone averages 25 ppg for for a decade and is on pace to score 30,000 points (which is the objective of basketball) YES

Melo is one of the most dynamic and unique scorers in NBA history. Just cause he has a shyt attitude and is completely washed now doesn't mean he wasn't a dominant player in his prime. He wasn't no slouch ever.

Carmelo's advantages were points off volume.
Manu's advantages were...everything else about basketball.

 

[Stick Up Kid]

Manu has the higher career TS%, WS/48 and vorp values.
Not even close.

If you dont get these cac' made up stats out the Coli



Manu > Melo tho

 

[FukkaPaidEmail]

Manu got to play with the greatest PF of all time,HOF PG Tony Parker,The youngest Finals MVP of all time and a GOAT level coach.


This is An insane comparison

 

[brick james]

Manu won a ring averaging 9 points on under 40% shooting get this disrespectful thread the fukk outta here

 

[Remote]

If you dont get these cac' made up stats out the Coli



Manu > Melo tho

I wonder the race of the man who made up "points" and "rebounds"