i'm not a hater, but i was around when the album dropped. yes, numbers didn't determine if people fukked with you and illmatic, the infamous and a couple of other classic albums did similar numbers. but reasonable doubt was not one of those albums. jay-z was that breh in the foxy brown video and resonable doubt was on nobodies radar. it wasn't considered an underground classic, it was just one of many mafioso rap albums dropping at the time. i remember a source article covering the puff daddy and the family tour in 1997 calling jay, who was a support act, an "overrated technician" and his performance forgettable
i'm not hating on

i like a lot of his records (including reasonable doubt) and think that the blueprint is one of the best albums ever recorded in rap. i'm just calling it as it is. jay blew up in '98 with hard knock life, before that, he was on nobodies list. but beginning with the promotion of the blueprint, jay started to rewrite history. there was a huge marketing campaign that culminated in his "retirement" and the black album, trying to make jay the greatest rapper ever and the king of ny. but the truth is, that his first album, while pretty good in retrospect, wasn't considered a classic until jay started saying that it was so often, that people began to repeat it. we can argue that it was slept on, but it was never a classic. the same is true for his own status in rap. jay was never the hottest rapper out, there was always somebody bigger than him. from his debut in 96 to his retirment in 2003 and the whole president carter shtick, tupac, nas, biggie, eminem, dmx, ja rule and 50 cent were all bigger then him. in every single year, somebody else was the hottest rapper. jay was the most consistent rapper, starting the trend to drop an album every year, releasing a couple if singles that did pretty well and going one or two times platinum with every album after vol. 2. but he was never the hottest rapper, he never outsold everybody else and he was never king of ny (at least at a time when that title still meant something). he had a nice consistent run from '98 until 2003 and somehow managed to inflate his own status by claiming that he was bigger than he actually was