Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen?

Is Mahomes the best QB you've ever seen

  • Yes

    Votes: 141 56.2%
  • No

    Votes: 110 43.8%

  • Total voters
    251

Vandelay

Life is absurd. Lean into it.
Joined
Apr 14, 2013
Messages
25,354
Reputation
6,988
Daps
91,401
Reppin
Phi Chi Connection
Brady led the NFL in TDs in 2002

In 2005 he was #1 in passing yards
Good call out. I missed that because he didn't go to the playoffs that year.

What I'm getting at is, there was some discussion once he had that 3rd ring, but it wasn't unanimous until he got Moss. They weren't saying he was GOAT'ed with 1 ring and 1 TD leading season. Pat has been in MVP contention every single year he has played. Brady was NOT on his trajectory over the same span of years.

Although I know it's a pass favorable league now, he might not have the yards or TDs, but he'd still be pulling off mind-bending passes.

On pure talent he's in the conversation. On pure stats he's in the conversation. If Pat does nothing else, he's Rodgers status already. If he gets 3 rings, I think it's undeniable.
 

FabTrey

Superstar
Joined
Apr 2, 2017
Messages
13,432
Reputation
-1,523
Daps
29,320
Good call out. I missed that because he didn't go to the playoffs that year.

What I'm getting at is, there was some discussion once he had that 3rd ring, but it wasn't unanimous until he got Moss. They weren't saying he was GOAT'ed with 1 ring and 1 TD leading season. Pat has been in MVP contention every single year he has played. Brady was NOT on his trajectory over the same span of years.

Although I know it's a pass favorable league now, he might not have the yards or TDs, but he'd still be pulling off mind-bending passes.

On pure talent he's in the conversation. On pure stats he's in the conversation. If Pat does nothing else, he's Rodgers status already. If he gets 3 rings, I think it's undeniable.

1. Brady had 3 rings, all 3 comeback wins.

2. Belichick 4th and 2 stupidity away from playing Rex Grossman in the SB. With Reche Caldwell as a main WR.

3. Top 3 finishes twice in MVP voting

4. Led the league in passing yd once

5. Led the league in TD once

6. 10-0 to start the playoff career


Yall either too young or heavily influenced by anti brady narrative. Only time Brady ever was a game manager was in 2001 when he first started.

It's closer than yall think. Brady was perceived as a clear top 2 QB in the league in that pre moss era.

Put it this way. if Manning is Mahomes then Brady was Burrow, but with 3 rings.

And 2007 eradicated the perception that he doesn't put up numbers.


As great as Mahomes is, he does have kelce and stat friendly offence. Brady's early number was a result of heavily run oriented offense. Brady never had a deep threat like mahomes did early on.
 
Last edited:

b. woods

Peace
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
43,661
Reputation
14,162
Daps
163,602
1. Brady had 3 rings, all 3 comeback wins.

2. Belichick 4th and 2 stupidity away from playing Rex Grossman in the SB. With Reche Caldwell as a main WR.

3. Top 3 finishes twice in MVP voting

4. Led the league in passing yd once

5. Led the league in TD once

6. 10-0 to start the playoff career


Yall either too young or heavily influenced by anti brady narrative. Only time Brady ever was a game manager was in 2001 when he first started.

It's closer than yall think. Brady was perceived as a clear top 2 QB in the league in that pre moss era.

Put it this way. if Manning is Mahomes then Brady was Burrow, but with 3 rings.

And 2007 eradicated the perception that he doesn't put up numbers.


As great as Mahomes is, he does have kelce and stat friendly offence. Brady's early number was a result of heavily run oriented offense. Brady never had a deep threat like mahomes did early on.

Wasn't "4th and 2" in 2009? :patrice:
 

LexDiamonds

Superstar
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
4,894
Reputation
2,115
Daps
20,382
Reppin
Toronto
1. Brady had 3 rings, all 3 comeback wins.

2. Belichick 4th and 2 stupidity away from playing Rex Grossman in the SB. With Reche Caldwell as a main WR.

3. Top 3 finishes twice in MVP voting

4. Led the league in passing yd once

5. Led the league in TD once

6. 10-0 to start the playoff career


Yall either too young or heavily influenced by anti brady narrative. Only time Brady ever was a game manager was in 2001 when he first started.

It's closer than yall think. Brady was perceived as a clear top 2 QB in the league in that pre moss era.

Put it this way. if Manning is Mahomes then Brady was Burrow, but with 3 rings.

And 2007 eradicated the perception that he doesn't put up numbers.


As great as Mahomes is, he does have kelce and stat friendly offence. Brady's early number was a result of heavily run oriented offense. Brady never had a deep threat like mahomes did early on.
Brad used to benefit heavy from cheating though :skip:
 

Truefan31

Superstar
Joined
Jan 9, 2016
Messages
4,420
Reputation
661
Daps
13,182
This isn't the NBA I don't care about team accolades. He has underperformed but I'm talking just pure QB skill

Rodgers has some of the worst meltdowns in big games. Especially last year, Rodgers basically doing nothing in a home playoff game. Mahomes is more talented than Rodgers anyway.
 

Truefan31

Superstar
Joined
Jan 9, 2016
Messages
4,420
Reputation
661
Daps
13,182
No he isn't.
MArino is on another level from all these modern cats, he didn't have the offensive favored ruleset and he played in an era where QBs weren't coddled and protected and still put up those numbers.

I respect Marino. I watched his entire career, even in college.

Mahomes is better.
 

Truefan31

Superstar
Joined
Jan 9, 2016
Messages
4,420
Reputation
661
Daps
13,182
Rodgers had terrible to overrated teams his entire career in my opinion but to your credit we've never see Aaron do what Pat did last night and carry a complete corpse of a team on his back

But 1 SB is still more than the majority of QBs so I don't take that lightly

Rodgers has had teams that had no business losing. That L he took last year was egregious…….
 
Top