Honestly Avowed did decent imo. It had limited marketing and reached 19k steam ccu. I think it had more players than Indiana Jones. I do find it weird they don't market their games and rely on word of mouth but they go about that in the wrong way which is why there's not much fanfare with their games imo.If they found it too expensive to keep Tango open, (which is based in Japan and prob a bit cheaper than Canada) then idk what hope compulsion really has. its not like the next one will be a big hit
but that kind of goes for all their games, avowed, Hellblade 2, Indiana jones, flight sim, forza, etc. all these games just get dropped into the service with no marketing no fanfare, no real word of mouth or anything and everyone just moves on. people talk more about “game pass crushing it” more than they talk about any individual game on the service.
i doubt any of these games are making any real money, even with playstation ports.
Gamers will hate to hear this but most people don't want to play AA games. Sure, you get games like Ex33, but for every Ex33 you have hundreds of AA games that people pass on. It's why Microsoft going AA route with their games didn't catch much fanfare. The only way that did massive was Sea of Thieves, but all of the others didn't really capture many gamers. State of Decay performed pretty well for what it was but other than that most people didn't really touch their AA games. The internet always preaches about smaller games and AA, but most people gravitate towards grand AAA games because they feel it's it's more valuable. It's why you look at any sales chart it mainly consists of AAA games if you look at top 25 sales of the year.I've felt this same way they’re doing a disservice to their smaller titles from the OG Xbox studios because they heavily promote Activision/Bethesda games and make them multiplat (Doom, Oblivion, and THPS 3+4 for example are getting ads blasted on both Xbox and PS storefronts) while the smaller studios and New IPs just get the Gamepass treatment on the console they continue to devalue themselves.
If they're gonna go multiplat with all the big games they might as well let the smaller ones cook on other systems as well from the jump to give those IPs a real chance. They're basically relegating those games to "little brother" status because even if a new IP is a hit, it's hardly gonna get the same looks or promotion as their mutliplat games. Plus we all know that if an Xbox game does become some breakout hit, the PS/Switch2 ports are more or less inevitable down the line anyway. Might as well cash in on the game while initial hype is still there and all audiences can engage with it at once
The craziest thing is that had Microsoft actually made their games exclusive, the market would be MUCH more competitive right now and you could very well make the argument that Microsoft's software output has been better than both Nintendo/Sony within the past year or so. But they are 100% Activision+Bethesda Sponsored by Microsoft at this point and the Xbox brand as we've known it is dying a slow, quiet death.
Theoretically, focusing on shorter dev time and smaller titles would've made sense for gamepass approach. However, Microsoft is bad at marketing their games and don't know how to produce quality quickly. If they were able to go at the pace of Sega, then they would be in a much different situation .Sega has the formula in how game pass should work. Them being able to produce Yakuza/Like a Dragon game, Atlus RPG, and other games every 2 years is what Microsoft should've been working towards when they pivoted towards game pass. Of course you can still have your AAA games, but it should've mainly consisted of AA games and other games that are quick to make. Taking 5+ years to make Hellblade 2 is malpratice for how bad it flopped.
Microsoft thing is interesting if they were to go exclusvie. I don't think these games are enough to make playstation gamers move or undecided gamers to move to xbox. If you're an undecided gamer would you choose Indiana Jones, Hellbalde 2, South of Midnight, Avowed, The Outer World 2,Oblviion Remastered, Doom, etc. or would you choose Spider man 2, Ghost of Yotei, Astro Bot, Helldivers 2, Stellar Blade, Rise of Ronin, Silent Hill 2, Death Stranding 2, etc. I think even Sony at their weakest will still make people gravitate towards to Sony becasue their friends are most likely there and their name is worht more. They would of course get more hardware sales, but it still won't be enough because people outside of North America and UK don't f with Microsoft consoles.