It really goes to show you how the claims of whose game will and wont age well is really just bullshyt
You're on point there.
Think about this - from 2000-2007, Mike Bibby and Ray Allen were both peaking.
Around the end of that period both of them had some injuries hit, but Bibby completely fell off while Ray Allen was pumping out all-star appearances all the way until 2011.
Bibby was borderline useless by 2010 and retired by 2012. Ray was a vital part of a title team in 2013 and retired in 2014.
Ray was three years older than Bibby this whole time...which means he retired at 38 while Bibby retired at 33, and Ray looked better his last year too.
Was anyone going to predict that solely off of their games in 2000?