SPIN: Let's Establish A List Of Albums With Classic Impact That Didnt Have Classic Quality

NYtymes

All Star
Joined
Jul 13, 2015
Messages
1,609
Reputation
146
Daps
5,114

Life after death has incredible bars and production, massive commercial success and was critically acclaimed in the industry as well as in the streets...
Its arguably the best double disk album ever in hip hop.

GRODT is arguably the greatest debut ever in HipHop.

#classics
 

The Devil's Advocate

Call me Dad
Joined
Jun 1, 2012
Messages
36,376
Reputation
8,060
Daps
100,529
Reppin
Better to reign in Hell than serve in Heaven
..............and most people didn't take him seriously. and his next 2 outings were struggles.

this is why you don't use sales as a barometer.
I agreed it wasn't better than carter 2. But who the hell was wayne in the 90s? I was there. He was the little kid from juvys video. Him and Turk was the young boys

What it did was give him some numbers. Know to keep pushing him cause he could be a star. And let him continue to put out albums.

We saw that video and thought ok. Wayne ain't no damn bow wow and he got a ok song out. He doing his numbers. and he followed it up and followed it up until got his classic... what it did was build a good foundation

but better... hell no
 

TheRtist

Superstar
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
8,554
Reputation
-200
Daps
23,726
Life after death has incredible bars and production, massive commercial success and was critically acclaimed in the industry as well as in the streets...
Its arguably the best double disk album ever in hip hop.

GRODT is arguably the greatest debut ever in HipHop.

#classics

nah not with The Chronic & Doggystyle...but its up there tho, deserves to be in the conversation. Every song 50 had from that album was a single.
 

Wacky D

PROVOCATIVE POSTING
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
40,727
Reputation
419
Daps
36,910
I agreed it wasn't better than carter 2. But who the hell was wayne in the 90s? I was there. He was the little kid from juvys video. Him and Turk was the young boys

What it did was give him some numbers. Know to keep pushing him cause he could be a star. And let him continue to put out albums.

We saw that video and thought ok. Wayne ain't no damn bow wow and he got a ok song out. He doing his numbers. and he followed it up and followed it up until got his classic... what it did was build a good foundation

but better... hell no


with the exception of juvi, they were all young breh. BG, turk & wayne were all a year apart from each other. niccas just f*cked wit wayne the least. that doesn't make him into a baby. they just played up the young chit with him to compensate, it seems. plus, he was a draw for the children & females.

bow wow wasn't even out yet. and wayne was already a member of a "gangsta rap" group, which was already 2 albums deep.

I'm not tryna gas up TBIH. the underlying message is that I don't think highly of C2. theyre pretty much equals. 2 albums with crazy filler.
 

Wacky D

PROVOCATIVE POSTING
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
40,727
Reputation
419
Daps
36,910
Life after death has incredible bars and production, massive commercial success and was critically acclaimed in the industry as well as in the streets...
Its arguably the best double disk album ever in hip hop.

GRODT is arguably the greatest debut ever in HipHop.

#classics


ive heard much better bars & production.

I could care less about critical acclaim in the industry. that's just bullchit.

streets wouldn't have f*cked with it nearly as hard if biggie didn't die right before it dropped.

GRODT is nowhere near the greatest debut ever in hip-hop. NOWHERE NEAR!!!!!! not even a top 5 debut from queens.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
62,965
Reputation
9,006
Daps
200,181
Reppin
BX, NYC
Really all three major '08 releases Tha Carter 3, 808 & Heartbreak, and Paper Trail are good selection for this thread...
I'm not tryna gas up TBIH. the underlying message is that I don't think highly of C2. theyre pretty much equals. 2 albums with crazy filler.
C2 is hands down better than C1 to me. What songs did you consider filler? I feel like maybe you're more drawn to 1 because of Gillie's influence.
 

Wacky D

PROVOCATIVE POSTING
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
40,727
Reputation
419
Daps
36,910
Really all three major '08 releases Tha Carter 3, 808 & Heartbreak, and Paper Trail are good selection for this thread...

C2 is hands down better than C1 to me. What songs did you consider filler? I feel like maybe you're more drawn to 1 because of Gillie's influence.


I'm not drawn to C1 either. gillie's "influence"(lol) is too blatant to me. it was too much to stomach.

but C2 is like child's play in comparison to C1. he had his moments, but overall, C2 was a CLEAR step down from C1.

I never cared to learn the tracklist from C2. but yea, a lot of tacky stuff on there. "I'm the fireman fire fiff fiff fireman".:dead:
 

BO BARON

IT AIN'T $HIT!!!!
Joined
Apr 19, 2015
Messages
2,740
Reputation
-350
Daps
4,811
Reppin
Jackson, MS
Its really hard to produce gangsta rap classics in the 20th century especially pure gangsta rap

nikkas quick to question tm101, trap muzik, the documentary or grodt

Those album's would be certified iconic type classics had they came out in the early 90's
 

ZEB WALTON

ayo! - BEZ
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
10,945
Reputation
910
Daps
18,933
Reppin
No Father To MY Style.. A Son Unique
I agree with all these albums. Life After Death didn't influence shyt. .
I fukk with you bro but life after death didnt influence shyt? It only influenced EVERY major label hip hop album after it.

do i even have to explain that?

See many rappers catalogs post Lad and pre lad and see the glaring difference.
 

C-Styles

Superstar
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
6,232
Reputation
-97
Daps
14,141
Reppin
The Windy City
the disrespect muhf*ckas are giving to LAD and 2001 :snoop:

You fakkits wouldn't know what a CLASSIC album sound like if Dre brought his equipment to your bedroom, had biggie in the booth and created an album together right in front your face! :ohlawd:

2001 set the standard for how an album should sonically sound and opened the door for producers expanding their sound, gave Kanye and Just Blaze something to be inspired from, Scott Storch got a launching pad out of the album, Snoop solidified himself as a legend, EM became the new monster to be reckoned with after that album, Xzibit was put on the map, Dre was born again showing he will always be relevant at the snap of a finger :ufdup: Don't disrespect this album! I can f*ck with you saying its an IMPACT classic, but to say it wasn't at all, really??:dahell: stay out of ya feelings


and as far as LAD.... your fave rappers still can't emulate the blueprint biggie laid on how to make a cohesive balanced album :damn:

nuff said! :rudy:
 

ucanthandlethetruth

Failure is not a option
Joined
Sep 7, 2013
Messages
9,788
Reputation
4,143
Daps
34,863
Reppin
Planet of Hip Hop
the disrespect muhf*ckas are giving to LAD and 2001 :snoop:

You fakkits wouldn't know what a CLASSIC album sound like if Dre brought his equipment to your bedroom, had biggie in the booth and created an album together right in front your face! :ohlawd:

2001 set the standard for how an album should sonically sound and opened the door for producers expanding their sound, gave Kanye and Just Blaze something to be inspired from, Scott Storch got a launching pad out of the album, Snoop solidified himself as a legend, EM became the new monster to be reckoned with after that album, Xzibit was put on the map, Dre was born again showing he will always be relevant at the snap of a finger :ufdup: Don't disrespect this album! I can f*ck with you saying its an IMPACT classic, but to say it wasn't at all, really??:dahell: stay out of ya feelings


and as far as LAD.... your fave rappers still can't emulate the blueprint biggie laid on how to make a cohesive balanced album :damn:

nuff said! :rudy:
biggie dropped the goat album and rappers been copying and biting lines ever since the impact of LAD doesn't even need explanation
:deadrose:All I can do is laugh at this:mjlol:
I fukk with you bro but life after death didnt influence shyt? It only influenced EVERY major label hip hop album after it.

do i even have to explain that
?

See many rappers catalogs post Lad and pre lad and see the glaring difference.

This. no way anyone can question LAD impact but everyone is entitled to opinions even if there wrong.:heh:
 

Long Live The Kane

Tyrant Titan
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
17,149
Reputation
4,900
Daps
64,505
Carter 3...off the back of 2 classic albums in C1 & C2, and 3 straight classic mixtapes in Dedication 2, Drought 3 and the leaked C3 sessions ...it was a let down quality wise, but the impact steered the entire direction of hip hop since

Vol. 2 ...Hard Knock Life ...can't believe I'm the first to mention it...this is the album that MADE Jay-Z, was the dawn of the rocafella era, and pushed hov to tier 1 status...quality wise, it's somewhere in the bottom-middle of his catalog..but again, the impact literally altered hip hop history

GRODT ...already been mentioned
 

Lord Mecca

Eyes May Shine
Joined
Jun 9, 2012
Messages
3,894
Reputation
2,130
Daps
11,765
I fukk with you bro but life after death didnt influence shyt? It only influenced EVERY major label hip hop album after it.

do i even have to explain that?

See many rappers catalogs post Lad and pre lad and see the glaring difference.
:russ: like what???? You'd definitely have to explain that. Shortly after Life After Death in 97, hip-hop moved to the south to where it is today lol. Life after Death didn't influence shyt. Great album though.
 
Top