Who did he beat that was good? I can't remember him battling anyone that wasn't a scrub besides YK. I feel like he had worse comp than JC, Geechi and Iron. Please correct me if I'm wrong, going OFF memory.
I've already touched on this.
He's pushing for Shine, because the majority of his battles weren't on URL. It makes his opinion pretty much void.
Shine's strength of competition is extremely low in comparison to the guys you mentioned. However, because these battlers aren't ranked (like a top 25), he has a very valid argument for COTY.
Remember when Champion had that conference last year ranking the battlers? That list should have been like a preseason top 25 going into 2018. It should have been updated every quarter.
I agree with you. Shine's schedule is just too weak to win that award.