I mean, it's all there. Helluva coach when he has a good cupboard to work with. Outcoached Belichick to send Tom to TB. Took a game off the Chiefs in the playoffs when he had no business in 2018 with Marcus Mariota. 1 score away from beating Bengals to play Rams in SB. Done had numerous reg season wins vs Bills, Chiefs and 49ers + more all while having the most injured team in the league for 2 years straight at one point.
The evidence is all there. His main "deficiencies" were probably his last CPL OC hires/promotions and he's just ultra conservative. Like if people thing analytics has swung the pendulum too far in one direction, then he's the exact opposite. No spice at all. Players love him tho. Will motivate the shyt outta guys and can help wit technique a lot having played.
I'm indifferent fr tho just cuz I wanna see us fully embrace the modern passing times. Or, if we are gonna run, do it creatively like McDaniel or Shanahan and not just count on the uniqueness + strength of 22.
That loss was in the divisional round. Had they won they would have faced the Chiefs in the AFC championship
But he is a good coach , and gets a lot out of the team, particularly when the team has talent.