We need to have a conversation about streaming numbers for Hov's classics

LOST IN THE SAUCE

The Sauce Apostle
Joined
Jun 15, 2022
Messages
1,919
Reputation
859
Daps
6,761
Reppin
HONOLULU
This is why the young kids are always shytting on Jay, and calling him overrated. They go to his artist page on these streaming services and it directs them to shyt like Run This Town and Empire State of Mind. They don't know any of his shyt before BP3.
 

StatUS

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
31,186
Reputation
2,110
Daps
68,820
Reppin
Everywhere
Interesting, but Jay was Tidal exclusive for minute.

Different genre but what are Aaliyah's numbers compared to Jay? I feel like they both became fully avaliable on DSPs around the same time.
 

Pop123

Peace
Joined
May 13, 2012
Messages
30,871
Reputation
7,240
Daps
116,169
Reppin
NULL
Jay-z whole style didn’t age well bro…someone needed to say it, 🤷🏽‍♂️. It’s not just a lot of the albums and the sounds either, it’s just him as an artist. Even the bars don’t sound as crazy now as they did then. I wanted to make a thread on this a few months ago but forgot about it, lol.


🤷🏽‍♂️, still undoubtedly Top 3 regardless, off the impact/work/radio hits/influence alone
 

Alexander Wiggin

All Star
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
3,828
Reputation
1,600
Daps
11,855
Reppin
Paris Saint-Germain
He’s not lol.





Jay z 35 million monthly listeners

Ice cube 8 million monthly listeners


Jay's list is a great representation of what kind of artist he is. The kind that rely on other artists to stay relevant. The guy is on lupe's cole's kendrick's and drake's first albums. He forces himself on the features. Even watch the throne didn't really need him.

He always conducted his career as a hustler and business man so from that point of view, he did extremely well and gotta respect him for that. But from an artistic perspective he can't be consider the best. He still one of the goat tho
 

Cloud McFly

All Star
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
2,576
Reputation
1,135
Daps
10,370
Reppin
NULL
Never understood the lengths cats go to to try to diminish dude’s standing in rap. If you don’t like him, and his music is not for you, there is nothing wrong with that, but to constantly try to convince others that your opinion on him is the only one that everyone should have is weird. Cats straight up celebrate and revel in any kind of slight directed towards him.
 

Omerta

All Star
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
2,342
Reputation
412
Daps
6,162
Not going to get involved in the Stan shyt or try and downplay his quality as a rapper, but we can all fairly agree that Jay’s influence on young rappers or young crowds is much less than his superstar contemporaries like Tupac, Biggie, Nas, DMX, Cube, Wayne, 50, Snoop and many others right?

Every single one of those rappers is more beloved by younger rappers and younger crowds than Jay-Z. It’s incredibly strange.
 

Budda

Superstar
Joined
Jun 12, 2013
Messages
10,848
Reputation
942
Daps
28,249
Not going to get involved in the Stan shyt or try and downplay his quality as a rapper, but we can all fairly agree that Jay’s influence on young rappers or young crowds is much less than his superstar contemporaries like Tupac, Biggie, Nas, DMX, Cube, Wayne, 50, Snoop and many others right?

Every single one of those rappers is more beloved by younger rappers and younger crowds than Jay-Z. It’s incredibly strange.

Don’t agree I think only Big Tupac Wayne and maybe 50 have a bigger influence with a younger crowd.

Jay by far got the most haters out them all though and I think that’s partly due to the bias the media have had with him throughout his career, he’s been propelled as an East cost rep messiah businessman supremo leader of the industry so naturally many would hit back at that.

Amongst younger fans you’d definitely find more saying he’s overrated more than any other rapper of his time, but he gets more love from younger artists for his whole image and story, plent have called themselves the young or instert city here Jayz
 

DraymondT

Superstar
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
5,083
Reputation
1,747
Daps
28,347
Jay-z whole style didn’t age well bro…someone needed to say it, 🤷🏽‍♂️. It’s not just a lot of the albums and the sounds either, it’s just him as an artist. Even the bars don’t sound as crazy now as they did then. I wanted to make a thread on this a few months ago but forgot about it, lol.


🤷🏽‍♂️, still undoubtedly Top 3 regardless, off the impact/work/radio hits/influence alone

Jay's list is a great representation of what kind of artist he is. The kind that rely on other artists to stay relevant. The guy is on lupe's cole's kendrick's and drake's first albums. He forces himself on the features. Even watch the throne didn't really need him.

He always conducted his career as a hustler and business man so from that point of view, he did extremely well and gotta respect him for that. But from an artistic perspective he can't be consider the best. He still one of the goat tho

These are facts :manny:

Jay was never innovative musically as a rapper most the nikkas on those streams were.
Jay was just a different level sonically and lyrically of what some other cat already been doin. Conceptually and with the pen he just wasn't innovative or creative as the Nas, Biggie, Andre, Pac, Scarface, DMX, Redman, Cube, Common etc.

You could clock his eras, swag, rapping patterns, even albums to shyt that been done recently to it and had a heavy influence on what he'd do next. It don't take nothin away from his rappin ability but he stuck around because of business and financial moves, Beyonce connect and being able to rap better than 98% of his peers so even if he rode trends, got hot features. Zoomers now have an access to music from past that never before seen and they fr diggin through the crates and they not bein influenced in real time to marketing moves like doin collab albums wit arguably the biggest thing in music at the time (Kellz, Linkin Park, Ye - just look at how different and random those 3 are :mjlol: - if Ye ain't drop MBDTF and recover from the Taylor shyt like he did I bet WTT don't even happen lol
 

Bugzbunny129

All Star
Joined
Apr 14, 2020
Messages
3,647
Reputation
1,507
Daps
8,582
Yea i noticed jay shyt dont move the way other shyt moves myself.

I think Its because he didnt create his own sound and relied on others who already made hits with people (timbaland puff dre neptunes dupri). Also a lot of jay fans are trend hoppers in first place. They liked the singles, but the albums were never some great artistic works everytime out idgaf what anyone says. Blueprint black album RD are the closest to real legendary works. Vol 2 debatable because it was huge and i love it now more than then but idk if others do. I think its underrated if anythung by hip hop heads. Rest no.

I thini hes a def goat but im suprised how a lot dont know shyt about his catalog despite him supposably being #1. By the time jay had an established sound (the kanye just blaze era) everyone else was already on the wave and their shyt was a commercialized version of other shyt in first place. It was hot but only til tge next jay album.


was never an deep artistic innovator despite being a top mc imo anyway. He innovated being a nyc mc on other coasts sounds and turning them to hits. But once that sound reaches expiration noone going back and bumping them like that.
 
Last edited:
Top