winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
48,669
Reputation
4,168
Daps
73,295
Reppin
Michigan
started Bocchi the Rock. I was wondering why the reviews are so overwhelmingly positive for a supposed K-on clone, but thats cuz its really nothing like K-on in terms of direction and purpose.

K-On was ultimately about maximizing fun in a fleeting high school period, musical expertise being secondary to their everyday nonsensical club activities. Yui wasn't all that as a musician but she had endless charisma and found fun in everything and that was always the point. K-on was also an unabashed moe show that pandered to its audience.

Boochi is about overcoming social anxiety, irrational fears that can keep the talented from reaching their potential. Boochi is a god solo guitarist but has no self confidence and doesn't know how to work within a team. Lot more room for character development here that would lead to a satisfying payoff once she does reach her dream. Not really a moe show. No superficial pandering that I can see.

Similar to how a lot of sports anime use the sport as a vehicle to explore human themes, while (sometimes) providing accurate portrayals of that sport that may teach you more about it, Boochi is very much the same for band music and I can appreciate that. There's a few good musical anime that work like this (Kids on the Slope, Nodame Cantabile, Beck etc) and this seems to be another one. Its exceptionally good for a CGDCT show (but still a CGDCT show, so its never gonna be for everyone)
I dropped this. The main character was annoying as hell. I get she suffers from social anxiety but it dominates the show. Suletta in G-Witch suffers from that but 7-8 episodes in it doesn’t even really dominate her characterization anymore. Watching her freak out and panic over the littlest things just wore me down. Overall it felt like a K-On clone with a more annoying main character. At its core it’s a cute girls doing cute things show just like K-On.

I’d argue that premise would work better as a romance show where she meets a boy and he helps her with her social anxiety bringing her out of her shell.
 

tripleaamin

All Star
Joined
Apr 10, 2014
Messages
8,865
Reputation
1,039
Daps
12,304
I dropped this. The main character was annoying as hell. I get she suffers from social anxiety but it dominates the show. Suletta in G-Witch suffers from that but 7-8 episodes in it doesn’t even really dominate her characterization anymore. Watching her freak out and panic over the littlest things just wore me down. Overall it felt like a K-On clone with a more annoying main character. At its core it’s a cute girls doing cute things show just like K-On.

I’d argue that premise would work better as a romance show where she meets a boy and he helps her with her social anxiety bringing her out of her shell.
:dwillhuh:
I get these type of show aint for everyone I fail to see how it is just magically better if Nijika is male instead of female. Nijika is the one character that is willing to understand who she is. Not just there recognizing her guitar skills. This show's main focus should be music. If you added romance here either the music or comedy will suffer greatly. Those 2 things are amazing for this particular SoL comedy.
 

Consumed

Superstar
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
5,990
Reputation
1,400
Daps
16,122
Watched Violet Evergarden movie.

It had its moments, and Violet's character arc tied up nicely considering how she started, but the route they took in the end was....surprising to say the least. Didn't see it coming based on the TV series.

I dropped this. The main character was annoying as hell. I get she suffers from social anxiety but it dominates the show. Suletta in G-Witch suffers from that but 7-8 episodes in it doesn’t even really dominate her characterization anymore. Watching her freak out and panic over the littlest things just wore me down. Overall it felt like a K-On clone with a more annoying main character. At its core it’s a cute girls doing cute things show just like K-On.

I’d argue that premise would work better as a romance show where she meets a boy and he helps her with her social anxiety bringing her out of her shell.

I'm a little surprised you dropped this considering the things you tolerate in the genre, but I understand the criticism. She does develop overtime and that's part of the charm of the show. Where she is in episode 6 compared to episode 1 is night and day for her standards and the progression feels authentic as its tied to her confidence improving.

Agree to disagree on the second point. The worst romances tend to have vapid premises like that.

Girl/Guy has crippling anxiety, struggles with trauma - here's a teenage romantic interest that miraculously cures that. Wish fulfillment.
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
48,669
Reputation
4,168
Daps
73,295
Reppin
Michigan
Watched Violet Evergarden movie.

It had its moments, and Violet's character arc tied up nicely considering how she started, but the route they took in the end was....surprising to say the least. Didn't see it coming based on the TV series.



I'm a little surprised you dropped this considering the things you tolerate in the genre, but I understand the criticism. She does develop overtime and that's part of the charm of the show. Where she is in episode 6 compared to episode 1 is night and day for her standards and the progression feels authentic as its tied to her confidence improving.

Agree to disagree on the second point. The worst romances tend to have vapid premises like that.

Girl/Guy has crippling anxiety, struggles with trauma - here's a teenage romantic interest that miraculously cures that. Wish fulfillment.
I’ve just seen better shows even about music. Watching these moe blob shows is just unfulfilling and ultimately that’s what this is watching moe blob characters have mundane interactions most of the time. Difference here is one of the moe blobs here is crippled by her social anxiety. Feels like New Game, Comic Girls, and K-On and all those other shows just like it.

Kono Oto Tomare was way more interesting than this. Let’s pretend romance shows like that Oregairu and Tomozaki-Kun don’t exist that deal with characters suffering from social anxiety and emotional trauma meeting people of the opposite sex and working through their issues by connecting with others don’t exist.

 

Consumed

Superstar
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
5,990
Reputation
1,400
Daps
16,122
I’ve just seen better shows even about music. Watching these moe blob shows is just unfulfilling and ultimately that’s what this is watching moe blob characters have mundane interactions most of the time. Difference here is one of the moe blobs here is crippled by her social anxiety. Feels like New Game, Comic Girls, and K-On and all those other shows just like it.

Kono Oto Tomare was way more interesting than this. Let’s pretend romance shows like that Oregairu and Tomozaki-Kun don’t exist that deal with characters suffering from social anxiety and emotional trauma meeting people of the opposite sex and working through their issues by connecting with others don’t exist.

you're little too focused on the romance part of this. but i understand if that's your preference in these types of stories.
 

Balla

Superstar
Joined
Nov 17, 2017
Messages
11,544
Reputation
1,405
Daps
24,459
Yo I’m on Bleach 123 where the tongue ring dude is explaining that he knows so much about Ichigo and the events of what happened in the story.

Then randomly they start playing this fire ass beat.
:wow::wow:

I can’t find it and tryna avoid spoilers.

Anyone know what I’m talking about?
 

storyteller

Veteran
Joined
May 23, 2012
Messages
17,709
Reputation
5,897
Daps
67,259
Reppin
NYC
Man I started watching ChainSaw Man thanks yall hyping it






AYO what the fukk was that 8th Episode :picard:

Them Goons different :mjcry:

Consider everything before episode 8 to be the prologue. Now you're getting the real ish, and there's not much letting up once this joint gets off and running. I think episode 8 really surpassed the manga version of the events, so I'm VERY hype for what's to come.
 

LordDeathwatch

Valar Morghulis
Supporter
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
16,260
Reputation
17,385
Daps
80,387
Reppin
Baltimore, MD / Charlotte, NC
Yo I’m on Bleach 123 where the tongue ring dude is explaining that he knows so much about Ichigo and the events of what happened in the story.

Then randomly they start playing this fire ass beat.
:wow::wow:

I can’t find it and tryna avoid spoilers.

Anyone know what I’m talking about?
You talking about Shinji? Blonde, big teeth, diagonal cut on his bob? :mjlol:
 
Top