Who's your top 5 QB's All Time

[Remote]

I won’t rank them.

But here is a list of guys who I felt were special.

Joe Montana
Dan Marino
Michael Vick
Peyton Manning
Patrick Mahomes

Those guys were all seemingly on a different level in the NFL.

Someone like Drew Brees or Tom Brady or Aaron Rodgers or others might have had as good or better careers than those guys. They may have better resumes than those guys. But there is nothing particularly special about their athleticism or play that stands out to me. So I don’t consider them as especially noteworthy.

That’s my view.

I’m leaving out quarterbacks before 1980 because that was probably a very different game. Though there is a great argument that I am wrong for leaving out Fran Tarkenton.

 

[NOSaintsFan02]

Drew Brees
Pat Mahomes
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Taysom Hill

 

[Reggie]

Brady Montana Pat Manning Aaron

 

[producingfire]

Drew Brees
Pat Mahomes
Tom Brady
Joe Montana
Taysom Hill

Taysom Hill?

 

[JYoung24]

Rodgers should not be on anyone's top 5.

Playoff choker.

No he's not stop it

 

[JYoung24]

No order Peyton Rodgers maholmes Steve young Brees

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

I'm going off arm talent only (in no specific order)

Marino
Mahomes
Moon
Manning
Rodgers

 

[FAH1223]

No he's not stop it

He is.

7-9 in the postseason since 2010.

 

[JYoung24]

This is what happens when you recently retire and you crushed a lot of people's hopes and dreams. The thing with Brady to, is he looked absurdly normal, and yet clinical it's difficult to put into words. No one can deny he made teams better. One would think Rogers would have that level of success but nope. I mean if Rogers had the same accolades I think people would understand, but Brady... I think Rogers has more talent in the since of he can do more things, but Tom got every ounce of talent out of himself and elevated the team around him. Made receivers house hold names etc..

Rodgers has made a lot of shytty teams better and made receivers household names himself too this hate for Rodgers has to stop

 

[premier58]

No order Peyton Rodgers maholmes Steve young Brees

What is it with you always misspelling peoples mames? Its Mahomes, not Maholmes, not Mahommes, but Mahomes!!! Its Tyreek Hill, not Tariq!!

 

[JYoung24]

He is.

7-9 in the postseason since 2010.

That's a team record tho

 

[premier58]

Do quarteebacks throwing tds to themselves? Do they block for themselves?

 

[NoHalfWay]

also Tom has 3 first team all pro selections his career. Mahomes has 2 already

Tom got robbed of MVP last year but Mahomes will easily surpass Brady’s regular season MVP count within the next few years honestly

Wait until the Chiefs fukk around and draft one of those 1st round WR freaks coming out of college for Mahomes to throw to

 

[Admiral Ackbar]

Montana
Manning
Marino
Mahomes
Young.

 

[Stick Up Kid]

1. Brady
2. Montana
3. Warren Moon
4. Manning
5. 2010 Michael Vick.