In their primes, who do you take: Nash or Jkidd

?

  • Nash

    Votes: 87 29.8%
  • Kidd

    Votes: 205 70.2%

  • Total voters
    292

Luke Cage

Coffee Lover
Supporter
Joined
Jul 18, 2012
Messages
54,679
Reputation
20,340
Daps
279,536
Reppin
Harlem
I actually think Kidd was better past his prime. He developed a 3 ball and could still lock down players like lebron.
 

hayesc0

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,507
Reputation
8,373
Daps
118,866
If "nash was the system" then why wasnt he a superstar in dallas? Why did he have better stats at age 36 than he did at 26?

Why did Jeremy lin become a household name and why did kendall marshall almost lead the league in assists?

If nash never played for d'Antoni then no one would even mention his name anymore
This man gets it. I would rep you but I cant just did the other day.
 

ItzDaKiing

Freedom
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
4,058
Reputation
359
Daps
6,537
Did u hear yourself he made 3 finals and u say he did nothing :martin:
Making it means nothing if you don't win it. You're juat like everyone else that.got.tossed from the playoffs, just took a bit longer. Same reason why lebron goin to the finals 6 times don't impress me, dude lost 4 of em. That's not greatness.
 

OG Talk

Archived
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,699
Reputation
7,889
Daps
116,566
Reppin
Heaven on Earth
The glorifying of Kidd's rebounding prowess is funny. I mean, yeah he may have been a great rebounder but how important is a rebounding point guard? I'll take the guard that revolutionized the offensive game over a point guard that can grab rebounds
How did Nash revolutionize the offensive game?
 

MJ Truth

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
39,390
Reputation
3,929
Daps
156,506
breh...

Nash was in the 50/40/90 range several times while having last I checked (a while ago) 5 of the 8 top offenses in league history. There is a lot to talk about regarding usage (scoring) from the PG spot versus distribution(shot creation) but I'll keep it short - Nash's scoring blows Kidd out of the water and it isn't just by the %s. Nash was a high efficiency, mid usage PG that probably held his team back because he generally SHOULD have shot more - and he was already running GOAT level offenses. Think about how insane that is - we're talking about a guy that we really wanted to see in 05 that would look like Curry now (he wouldn't and that's another topic). Already wrecking the league offensively and he could still be somewhat faulted for not shooting enough. And then we have Kidd, a relatively low efficiency (and that's being nice) mid usage PG that we would want to shoot even less. Yes, that '13ppg' Kidd was averaging wasn't even generating enough offense to be league average. It actually might have been better if Kidd kept passing even if he was wide open for 3 - that's how bad his offense was compared to Nash. It's pretty much a Steph Curry versus Rondo situation and no one is stupid enough (this is thecoli though :francis:) to pick the latter.
Comparing Nash to Curry and then Kidd to Rondo and then using those comparisons to say Nash >>> Kidd is faulty thinking breh.
 

MJ Truth

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Feb 1, 2015
Messages
39,390
Reputation
3,929
Daps
156,506
Making it means nothing if you don't win it. You're juat like everyone else that.got.tossed from the playoffs, just took a bit longer. Same reason why lebron goin to the finals 6 times don't impress me, dude lost 4 of em. That's not greatness.
:snoop:
 

LV Koopa

Jester from Hell
Joined
Nov 18, 2014
Messages
9,567
Reputation
2,078
Daps
29,676
Reppin
NYC
If "nash was the system" then why wasnt he a superstar in dallas? Why did he have better stats at age 36 than he did at 26?

Why did Jeremy lin become a household name and why did kendall marshall almost lead the league in assists?

If nash never played for d'Antoni then no one would even mention his name anymore

Because the general public didn't actually understand what was happening in Dallas at the time. He was pretty damn good his last few years there. Marshall and Lin didn't have close to the impact Nash had under D'Antoni.
 

hayesc0

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,507
Reputation
8,373
Daps
118,866
Making it means nothing if you don't win it. You're juat like everyone else that.got.tossed from the playoffs, just took a bit longer. Same reason why lebron goin to the finals 6 times don't impress me, dude lost 4 of em. That's not greatness.
:usure: He did win one though lol just like Lebron has some rings.
 

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
44,713
Reputation
-815
Daps
93,007
Again if you had to start a team with one, 99% of GMs would pick kidd.

Nash is great but he didn't become a HOF until he played in Mike's system, you can argue he was the system, but if that was the case, why didn't he put up numbers like (phoenix) in dallas when he played with comparable or better offensive talent in a small ball system don nelson had?

imagine kidd on those early 00 dallas teams with dirk, fin, jamison, walker, etc.. I could see them making the finals in 03 (beating the spurs), or 04 beating that old laker team as well.
 

Houston911

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
47,536
Reputation
14,759
Daps
203,089
Because the general public didn't actually understand what was happening in Dallas at the time. He was pretty damn good his last few years there. Marshall and Lin didn't have close to the impact Nash had under D'Antoni.


Who implied that they had a similar impact? All that stuff is irrelevant.

The point is that d'antoni system elevates every pg who plays in it and makes them look better than they are

29 year old nash was a 2 time all star before linking with d'gawdtoni. He immediately won 2 mvp's. This has literally NEVER happened before. Nash put up better stats at 36 than he did at 26, this has NEVER happened before.

Jeremy lin was an undrafted nerd who couldnt buy playing time. He got with the maestro d'antoni and had People on sohh arguung that the knicks should trade melo and build around lin. They argued that lin would be better than kyrie irving and john wall.

Kendall marshall finished 2nd in the ENTIRE NBA in assists per game

RAYMOND FELTON WAS AVERAGING 17 AND 9

Someone would have to be foolish to believe all of this is a coincidence. Every knowledgeable basketball fan has accepted the fact that d'antoni meant more to nash than nash meant to d'antoni.

Nba players openly discuss this

Every pg in the draft (lawson, steph curry, brandon jennings, etc) wanted to go to ny cuz they knew that d'antoni could make a decent pg look like a borderline allstar, and he could make a borderline all star look like a hall of famer.

I remember games where the corpse of baron davis had 10 assists in less than 20 minutes playing for d'antoni :dead:
 

OG Talk

Archived
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,699
Reputation
7,889
Daps
116,566
Reppin
Heaven on Earth
The glorifying of Kidd's rebounding prowess is funny. I mean, yeah he may have been a great rebounder but how important is a rebounding point guard? I'll take the guard that revolutionized the offensive game over a point guard that can grab rebounds

To answer this question its pretty important and creates an instant advantage.. First off it gives your team extra possessions and opportunities to score.. Secondly it really stimulates the fast break and can lead to easy transition points down the floor. Because the rebounder is the primary ball handler, so it takes away the need of DeAndre Jordan making an outlet pass that can possibly be a turnover...

Just watch Russell Westbrook for an example..
 

OG Talk

Archived
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,699
Reputation
7,889
Daps
116,566
Reppin
Heaven on Earth
Who implied that they had a similar impact? All that stuff is irrelevant.

The point is that d'antoni system elevates every pg who plays in it and makes them look better than they are

29 year old nash was a 2 time all star before linking with d'gawdtoni. He immediately won 2 mvp's. This has literally NEVER happened before. Nash put up better stats at 36 than he did at 26, this has NEVER happened before.

Jeremy lin was an undrafted nerd who couldnt buy playing time. He got with the maestro d'antoni and had People on sohh arguung that the knicks should trade melo and build around lin. They argued that lin would be better than kyrie irving and john wall.

Kendall marshall finished 2nd in the ENTIRE NBA in assists per game

RAYMOND FELTON WAS AVERAGING 17 AND 9

Someone would have to be foolish to believe all of this is a coincidence. Every knowledgeable basketball fan has accepted the fact that d'antoni meant more to nash than nash meant to d'antoni.

Nba players openly discuss this

Every pg in the draft (lawson, steph curry, brandon jennings, etc) wanted to go to ny cuz they knew that d'antoni could make a decent pg look like a borderline allstar, and he could make a borderline all star look like a hall of famer.

I remember games where the corpse of baron davis had 10 assists in less than 20 minutes playing for d'antoni :dead:

I wish I could rep you twice

:wow:
 

No Homo

Superstar
Joined
May 14, 2012
Messages
18,909
Reputation
4,675
Daps
59,645
Reppin
Jigga with the Roley and the Vest
Who implied that they had a similar impact? All that stuff is irrelevant.

The point is that d'antoni system elevates every pg who plays in it and makes them look better than they are

29 year old nash was a 2 time all star before linking with d'gawdtoni. He immediately won 2 mvp's. This has literally NEVER happened before. Nash put up better stats at 36 than he did at 26, this has NEVER happened before.

Jeremy lin was an undrafted nerd who couldnt buy playing time. He got with the maestro d'antoni and had People on sohh arguung that the knicks should trade melo and build around lin. They argued that lin would be better than kyrie irving and john wall.

Kendall marshall finished 2nd in the ENTIRE NBA in assists per game

RAYMOND FELTON WAS AVERAGING 17 AND 9

Someone would have to be foolish to believe all of this is a coincidence. Every knowledgeable basketball fan has accepted the fact that d'antoni meant more to nash than nash meant to d'antoni.

Nba players openly discuss this

Every pg in the draft (lawson, steph curry, brandon jennings, etc) wanted to go to ny cuz they knew that d'antoni could make a decent pg look like a borderline allstar, and he could make a borderline all star look like a hall of famer.

I remember games where the corpse of baron davis had 10 assists in less than 20 minutes playing for d'antoni :dead:

I was coming in to talk about how felton was killin under dantoni. :dead:
 
Top