In their primes, who do you take: Nash or Jkidd

[Box Factory]

wooda coulda

its all hypotheticals

Nah, those were terrible playoff teams. Getting to the finals by beating terrible teams and then getting swept in embarassing fashion like the 2002 Nets did isn't something that deserves praise.


Also "Nash played soft" is a very untrue statement

 

[Juggalo Fred]

I took Nash in our coli all time league, Kidd in the bench

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

nash was a better shooter but kidd improved his 3pt shot later in his career and that's what helped him win a ring. Maybe if nash would've improved his defense it would've given phoenix a better shot to win.Kidd improved his weakness nash never did

You're not serious with this post are you?

 

[Jplaya2023]

You're not serious with this post are you?

kidd improve the weak link of his game and helped his team win. Why couldn't nash? parker used to kill phoenix back in those days

 

[Houston911]

I'm gonna go with the guy who didn't need to play for dantoni to be transformed into a superstar

How can I compare Jason Kidd to a guy who wasn't considered a superstar until he was 30?

 

[Supreme365]

Kidd.. In his Prime he would be a Top Point Guard in any Era..

So would nash

 

[Supreme365]

Kidd didn't accomplish shyt I don't care about the Dirk championship or his trips to the finals in the weakest conference ever

How can you say he didn't accomplish shyt then proceed to list his accomplishments

 

[Supreme365]

Michael Carter-Williams has a better all around game than Steph Curry

who's better

The fukk are you talking about no he doesnt

 

[The Fire]

anyone picking Kidd is delusional

 

[The Fire]

Lol at "gets rebounds" as a valid argument this isn't fantasy

 

[Street Knowledge]

Nash destroys kidd as an offensive player and that's all that matters. Scoring shooting handles etc. Kidd's defense and rebounding at the PG position is not enough to make up for that gap.

Kidd isn't doing this to nobody in the playoffs

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Nash destroys kidd as an offensive player and that's all that matters. Scoring shooting handles etc. Kidd's defense and rebounding at the PG position is not enough to make up for that gap.

Kidd isn't doing this to nobody in the playoffs

This man gets it.

 

[Juggalo Fred]

Nash destroys kidd as an offensive player and that's all that matters. Scoring shooting handles etc. Kidd's defense and rebounding at the PG position is not enough to make up for that gap.

Kidd isn't doing this to nobody in the playoffs

yep, this is why he's starting on my All Time Coli team and Kidd is his back up

 

[Draje]

Nash destroys kidd as an offensive player and that's all that matters. Scoring shooting handles etc. Kidd's defense and rebounding at the PG position is not enough to make up for that gap.

Kidd isn't doing this to nobody in the playoffs

I don't think nikkas remember Prime Nash in the playoffs but that nikka was COOKING cats. Nash was damn near un-guardable so the goal was typically to just try to go at him all the time on defense to fire him out.

 

[nieman]

I don't think nikkas remember Prime Nash in the playoffs but that nikka was COOKING cats. Nash was damn near un-guardable so the goal was typically to just try to go at him all the time on defense to fire him out.

Prime Nash in the playoffs was past his prime.

Kidd thrived in multiple offenses. 3J Mavs, Suns with KJ, Suns w/o KJ, Nets slow offense, Mavs again. Hell, Kidd's prime was since entering the league until 2nd stint with Mavs. It shouldn't be a contest. He's played fast break, fast paced, Princeton, half-court, and PG dominated offenses. he stepped up and was the leading scorer for a team that had no true scorer. He's gotten far more players paid than Nash.

When Phx got rid of D'Antoni, do y'all not remember how Nash struggled until they implemented the old offense? AND when Mavs exchanged Nash for JET, they were in the finals...an all iso offense.