Breh at this point is there any question about Beyoncé being the female GOAT

[Maximus]

See, this is where it gets complex. Just reading this thread is hilarious.

The sheer and utter delusion when it comes to Beyonce’s Beyhive is what makes people so overly critical of her and I don’t think her fans realize it.

Bey is dope. The best female entertainer of this era. No question. But when people start trying to equate her to MJ and Prince and people like that, it just creates a situation for her to get dragged.

Bey doesn’t need to be compared to them. She can be great on her own merits. And I wish her stans realized this instead of doing the fukkin most all the time.

I'm not overly critical of her. I never denied that she's a good live performer, she's just not on the level of the people I named. Look at Sammy Davis, Jr. who could sing well, dance well, play multiple instruments(he was doing that long before Prince), in addition to doing comic impressions all in the same show. Or The Marvelettes who had complicated dance routines, yet could still hit high notes without breaking a sweat.

James Brown, Jackie Wilson, I mean the list goes on and on.

I keep hearing Bey fans go on and on about her singing and dancing well at the same time when she's not even close to the first to do that! Nearly every singer/dancer from the past did that well and better than her. So, it just shows either an ignorance of musical history or disrespect towards it.

Beyonce is sort of like this generation's Tina Turner, only her dancing isn't as good and her voice isn't as soulful. She also has some Diana Ross/Janet/Michael elements sprinkled in, but she doesn't match the all-time greats in live performance.

 

[CASHAPP]

Lies. I usually fukk with you in these discussions, but we not gonna disregard Janet.

She has executive producer AND writing credits on Control, Velvet Rope, and Rhythm Nation. Three of the best albums from a female artist EVER.

Janet >> Whitney >> Beyoncé.

So do popstars today. Yet you quick to say they paid off writers and producers to get those credits.

How is Janet any different? Yes she had alot of input just like other popstars say they did today, but you can't think one is lying but then think Janet is truthful just cause of nostalgia.

Janet didn't write or produce let it go.

She is still a legend, has one of the best catalogs and the best female performer ever.

You guys are way too obsessed with people writing. People in the past didn't care about Gladys, Aretha and Patti not writing. Shut the hell up with the writing obsessions.

 

[IllmaticDelta]

An overhyped dancer.

The GOAT. Above Whitney ? Aretha ? Nina ? Give me break.

Some of you need a re-education on black music.

I'm disgusted.

whitney and aretha are great vocalist but they ARE NOT stage show performers. Their vocals is what made them great

nina her stage show was in her live instrumentation (she was a musical beast on the piano) + signing but she was not a physical perfomer

The greatest total package for black female acts prior to beyonce was Tina Turner and then janet jackson. beyonce has better vocals than both of them

the greatest combo of voice and stage show for black females w/o question is beyonce

 

[Flywin Lannister]

Beyonce is the first African American woman to headline Coachella and went out with a bang. She payed homage to...
Nina Simone
Malcolm X
Dawn Penn
Sang “lift every voice”
Swag surfed
CMurder
brought out an HBCU like band with dancers and had a probate AND stepped on stage
DC reunion was everything
Jay Z....



The entrance tho























@Otis Kane Jr. @stomachlines @BmoreGorilla @Azul @LovelyOne83 @Paradise @father of men @ByAnyMeans @Ask a Stupid Question

DJEEZUS she is on a completely different level

For clarity: nobody fukks with MJ, it's a different planet but not counting MJ when you make the individual comparison - she is on a TOTALLY different level, she is so versatile, talented and has assembled an amazing team that puts her in a position to truly showcase her range and skills. How can we not all be proud of this sister? She is not a sell-out, she is repping us 100% as always. AMAZING. One of the only real ones, and she's #1. Thank you OP for sharing these tweets!

 

[brownsugah]

Imagine being taunted and bullied because people don’t agree with the majority and are praising Beyonce’s Performance skills (in addition to having a difference of opinion). I see why people say The Locker Room is trash.

 

[Flywin Lannister]

Me too, but calling her better than mike would've gotten this thread bushed so I left it alone.

It's a free world, people are entitled to their opinion even if history and universal opinion suggests something else - what kind of mods does this forum have that that could get a thread bushed...? The entire CONCEPT of a forum is free speech...

 

[IllmaticDelta]

how old are you? seriously. Madonna,

madonna can't sing but can dance

Janet,

janet can't sing as good as beyonce but can dance

Tina Turner,

tina turner is actaully the goat black female performer prior/total package to beyonce. beyonce is a superior singer....tied in perfomance though

hell even Britney spears has put on shows like this before.

she's 100%

It's a new era and she's by herself, the industry is different, but don't let that confuse you into thinking that Beyonce invented this shyt.

some of you beyhive are literally out of your minds.

beyonce is the best combo of vocals and performance/stage show of all time for female acts

 

[Booker T Garvey]

We all know you're a trash poster who supports the killing of innocent people by Muslim terrorists (this is documented on The Coli breh)

But... vocally she is sub par?

Barely anything you said made any sense.. but vocally she's sub par...



To think that IN REAL LIFE people know you, they must be so fukking annoyed each time they know they will actually be in a room with you alone that day breh.. and puzzy.. forget about it. You must have 11 Fleshlights

I’ve heard this complaint about Beyonce for over a decade and I don’t get it.

She can sing her ass off, not sure what people are listening to but she’s amazing

The actual songs she sings is a separate discussion, but vocals? No auto tune needed.

 

[brownsugah]

It's a free world, people are entitled to their opinion even if history and universal opinion suggests something else - what kind of mods does this forum have that that could get a thread bushed...? The entire CONCEPT of a forum is free speech...

Well people can't take free speech on here. As I can tell. SMH. I've been called a "dummy" several times for what I said in here. It's like what's the point of a forum if you can't speak your mind..even if its done in a respectful manner?!

 

[TheDarkCloud]

I’ve heard this complaint about Beyonce for over a decade and I don’t get it.

She can sing her ass off, not sure what people are listening to but she’s amazing

The actual songs she sings is a separate discussion, but vocals? No auto tune needed.

But but but Adele...

Sorry breh. I had to do it.

 

[Idaeo]

Just of the strength of her stamina...the ability to give 2 hour performances without missing a beat, breath, or note.

Her dancers and band were sweating like hell by the end...Beyoncé looked like she just started.

At this point, all you contrarians are just exposing yourselves. No one with two eyes and ears can look at that performance and say anyone else does it better than her.

 

[Booker T Garvey]

madonna can't sing but can dance

janet can't sing as good as beyonce but can dance

tina turner is actaully the goat black female performer prior/total package to beyonce. beyonce is a superior singer....tied in perfomance though

she's 100%


beyonce is the best combo of vocals and performance/stage show of all time for female acts

For the second time, I was addressing the high energy show part, not talent or who’s better -

Beyonces performance will go down in history

But those of us over 30 have seen this before, and set to better music too

 

[Booker T Garvey]

But but but Adele...

Sorry breh. I had to do it.

Whatever this means

I mean of you want to shift the discussion to SALES I’ll b-b-but Adele you into a little ball in the corner

I don’t have an emotional attachment to these singers like you cats, I’m speaking facts and facts only.

 

[brownsugah]

Just of the strength of her stamina...the ability to give 2 hour performances without missing a beat, breath, or note.

Her dancers and band were sweating like hell by the end...Beyoncé looked like she just started.

At this point, all you contrarians are just exposing yourselves. No one with two eyes and ears can look at that performance and say anyone else does it better than her.

Thank you!!! Damnit!!

 

[Flywin Lannister]

whitney and aretha are great vocalist but they ARE NOT stage show performers. Their vocals is what made them great

nina her stage show was in her live instrumentation (she was a musical beast on the piano) + signing but she was not a physical perfomer

The greatest total package for black female acts prior to beyonce was Tina Turner and then janet jackson. beyonce has better vocals than both of them

the greatest combo of voice and stage show for black females w/o question is beyonce

All facts^ Super talented singers, but nobody fukks with Beyonce on stage. Can't argue with this logic @African Peasant (btw for all the pro-black militant hypeness there are only 2 Usernames that start with 'African' on The Coli......)