No you are arguing against reparations.
I seen this happen in every internet video and thread with Leftists and reparations.
Leftists got a whole list of shyt that they want. Then here comes reparations.
"But how are we gonna pay for it?"
"What are reparations exactly?"
"But what about the immigrants?"
"How are we are gonna know who to give it to?"
Even Black people do this, but somehow people can conceive of free college, free healthcare, affordable housing, universal basic income.
But when it comes to reparations majority of leftists do this:
I'll say it again and I say it all the time. We are not politicians, it is not our job to figure out ways for the government to do things. The idea that the government operates like a business is intentionally put into the minds of the people to limit their asks and their imagination.
We know that governments don't operate like a business because businesses and the wealthy hide money, they steal money, they clean money, they make fake ass shell corporations and the government lets them keep it - but they cut social programs and cut taxes and then tell us they have no money.
This whole, "how are we gonna pay for reparations", is racism. It is benign neglect.
Countries been paying reparations to Jews forever. Germany even paid war debt for WW2 for decades and their economy is alright.