Prime Paul pierce Or Current Melo?

[GoldenGlove]

Cause you trying to hold some stupid shyt like Melo losing in the first round against him like other NBA legends havent went through the same thing.

Nobody's trying to compare Melo to Jordan and Magic. I just pointed out that other nikkas have went through the same shyt Melo has gone through. That's fukking retarded to try to hold some shyt like that against Carmelo

Yet, the only person to mention these nikkas in this thread was you.

Thread is about Melo and Pierce in their prime. Are we not to talk about how they've played in the postseason? Stop bringing up Legends trying to minimize the fact that Melo's teams have struggled to even force 6 game series in the first round. Not even talking about him losing the series at this point. Talking about how easily his squads have been bounced.

 

[Ineedmoney504]

Im a Celtics fan but im choosing melo easily, paul peirce was always a second tier player imo, he never was elite, melo is a top tier player and just a beast, and he the best scorer in the league, I just cant forget how he use to get lit up by kerry kitties, keith van horne and Richard jefferson, they really couldnt ever beat the nets, pierce legacy wouldnt be shyt without kg, kg already a hof before the 08 ship

 

[Lakers Offseason]

To me, Pierce game > Melo's game. Pierce could take it to the hoop better than Melo. Draw contact and get to the FT line. Pierce was better in the clutch too.

 

[KingJudah]

To me, Pierce game > Melo's game. Pierce could take it to the hoop better than Melo. Draw contact and get to the FT line. Pierce was better in the clutch too.

 

[ManBearPig]

To me, Pierce game > Melo's game. Pierce could take it to the hoop better than Melo. Draw contact and get to the FT line. Pierce was better in the clutch too.

are there anybody who voted for Pierce that didn't had a stupid reason behind their selection?

 

[Youhadasparkwhenustarted]

Melo without hesitation.

When Malta says it, then I know ya'll other nikkas is wrong.

 

[GreatestLaker]

When Malta says it, then I know ya'll other nikkas is wrong.

Its sad when you can't form an opinion for yourself and take another man's word as gospel.

 

[holidayinn21]

fukk both of these ho ass nikkas, but i guess I'll go with melo.

neither are top-tier IMO.

 

[holidayinn21]

When Malta says it, then I know ya'll other nikkas is wrong.

what kind of fukk shyt is this?

 

[Youhadasparkwhenustarted]

Its sad when you can't form an opinion for yourself and take another man's word as gospel.

That post was in jest. It's not gospel to me, just recognize him as few of the objective and knowledgeable posters when it comes to basketball on here, so his opinions are actually worth considering compared to the rest of you

 

[gho3st]

Melo's teams never went 24-58


I'd still take Prime Melo > Pierce. Pierce before garnett and ray allen was

 

[Suiken]

Melo's teams never went 24-58


I'd still take Prime Melo > Pierce. Pierce before garnett and ray allen was

You are talking like Pierce wasn't injured that season

If we are using that logic, then David Robinson sucks because he led his team to a 20-62 record.

 

[StatUS]

I think Melo is the better player here.

 

[Flight]

Melo.

 

[NY's #1 Draft Pick]

To me, Pierce game > Melo's game. Pierce could take it to the hoop better than Melo. Draw contact and get to the FT line. Pierce was better in the clutch too.

Who has the most gamewinning shots of all time in the nba?