Was there a big talent gap between Tom Brady and the QB's in his era?

[Based Lord Zedd]

Can u read? I said Manning is better than Rodgers in the regular season. But id take Rodgers over Manning in the playoffs because Rodgers was better.

Stop being such a stan about this

Rodgers numbers are better than Mannings in the post season with less games played. Thats a fact

Rodgers postseason numbers are better than Brady too, you taking him first in the postseason?

You'd also need to consider taking Josh Allen over Rodgers using this logic.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

@Juggalo Fred posting Barry mcockiner? He's the king of cherry picked stats

He’s not wrong about the New England defenses… and that Tampa Bay defense was probably top 15…. Brady has 2 rings where the other team didn’t even score a touchdown… and has another ring only throwing for a buck and some change

 

[premier58]

He’s not wrong about the New England defenses… and that Tampa Bay defense was probably top 15…. Brady has 2 rings where the other team didn’t even score a touchdown… and has another ring only throwing for a buck and some change

Most defenses that won in history were top 10 in scoring def, though.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

Most defenses that won in history were top 10 in scoring def, though.

Strong possibility….. and the main reason why the way QBs are discussed and ranked is extremely flawed. I kind of wanna see if the QB market value is effected if Purdy gets the win in the Super Bowl

 

[Piff Perkins]

People def generally felt Manning and Rodgers were more talented. But I also remember with Manning there was a constant "but in the playoffs..." caveat at the time that kept him out of convos when it came to who was better. Brady was constantly beating Manning.

 

[Controversy]

He’s not wrong about the New England defenses… and that Tampa Bay defense was probably top 15…. Brady has 2 rings where the other team didn’t even score a touchdown… and has another ring only throwing for a buck and some change

The key to winning super bowls is not playing like superman, the key is limiting mistakes and making timely plays

Hurts played like superman last yr, made one critical mistake, and my team lost

Brady limited mistakes in the SB and that's why his teams won 70% of the time in the big game

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

The key to winning super bowls is not playing like superman, the key is limiting mistakes and making timely plays

Hurts played like superman last yr, made one critical mistake, and my team lost

Brady limited mistakes in the SB and that's why his teams won 70% of the time in the big game

You also can’t let the other team score more than you…. You can play mistake free ball as a QB and have decent numbers, but if your squad still loses then the media will use the narrative that the QB didn’t do enough

 

[010101]

This is some amateurish garbage because when it comes to production with context thrown in, the two best QB, performance wise, are Brady and Manning. It has absolutely nothing to do with winning.

winning is the point of playing*

 

[K.Y.R.I.E]

Brady the goat period

 

[Controversy]

You also can’t let the other team score more than you…. You can play mistake free ball as a QB and have decent numbers, but if your squad still loses then the media will use the narrative that the QB didn’t do enough

teams generally lose bc they turn the ball over in the SB more than their opponent

 

[Based Lord Zedd]

People def generally felt Manning and Rodgers were more talented. But I also remember with Manning there was a constant "but in the playoffs..." caveat at the time that kept him out of convos when it came to who was better. Brady was constantly beating Manning.

Manning is 3-2 vs Brady in the playoffs.

 

[Field Marshall Bradley]

teams generally lose bc they turn the ball over in the SB more than their opponent

The QB can throw a bad pick or a DB can make a great pick….. Malcolm Butler is an example of a DB making a great pick to win a game(Super Bowl)

 

[Controversy]

The QB can throw a bad pick or a DB can make a great pick….. Malcolm Butler is an example of a DB making a great pick to win a game(Super Bowl)

Brady completed 37 passes for only 328 yds in that Seattle game...which demonstrates he took what the def gave and didn't try to be superman

 

[Tony D'Amato]

If Peyton Manning had Andy Reid or a competent coach all those yrs in Indy, Brady would loss more and Peyton woulda won more. Peyton Manning was the goat regular season qb

 

[MegaTronBomb!]

Repeating yourself doesn't make what you say any less false. Dude just showed you QBs who stepped into a better spot

I'm going to take this as that you don't comprehend that well.

just some of the "dudes nobody remembered"
-Corey Dillon
-Randy Moss
-Wes Welker
-Julian Edelman
-Gronk
- some dead guy
- Ty Law
- Richard Seymour
- Lawyer Milloy
- Vinatieri
- Vince Wilfork
- Willie McGinest
- Jerod Mayo
- Rodney Harrison
- Asante Samuel
- Stephon Gilmore