I really get the sense that you believe mainstream success and talent are synonymous?
Not in the slightest..but I understand how you come to that conclusion...it's a nuanced point that I'm making and "oh so you think sales mean you're the best

" is one of the easiest strawmen to construct...there are definitely talents that lend themselves to success, like songwriting and hitmaking, but success in and of itself is not synonymous with talent...this concept of being "that dude" is not even solely tied to success, especially not strictly mainstream success...I'm talking the guys that are impacting, dictating and directing the pulse of the game...in the way that Rick Ross has been contention for it while never sniffing a platinum plaque, while a guy like Macklemore who's bout to touch a million and has multiple #1 one pop hits ain't even on the ballot...it takes a bit of objectivity, that for whatever reason a lot of people simply don't have, to be honest with yourself and admit when somebody is that dude who you may not particularly dig as much as the hip hop populace at large does...but at the end of the day, certain shyt just can't be denied...like I hold it as almost a badge of honor to be one of the biggest 50 Cent haters on the site, but I'm first to admit that he was in unquestionably that dude or in contention during his run in the mid 2000s...I hate the Heat more than is prolly physically healthy, but they got the chip
Which leads me to this:
Drake is nowhere near being top 5 "that dude" unless you exclude quality of music as a factor.

Name me who are the top 5 rap game MVPs candidates over let's say the last 2 years....because if Drake not only isn't one of them, but nowhere close...you're either in flat out denial or completely out of touch with the current pulse of the game...there's certain shyt that are just fundamental observable facts, that you may not agree with or are unhappy about, but are truth in reality nevertheless
What anthem does Drake have? Take Care? Find Your Love? Best I Ever Had?
The closest he's come to matching quality with mainstream impact was The Motto. I'll give him that. That was a huge song where his verse was top shelf.
If I told you Started From the Bottom was one of the biggest anthems of this year...and that Drake singlehandedly took a random mixtape track from a random up and coming ATL rap group, threw a verse on it, and turned it into one of the biggest athems in hip hop this summer simply by virtue of being "that dude" right now ...what would be your response? a subjective qualitative critique of his verses? If so, I'm sorry...but tha's not really how anthems work
The issue isn't whether Drake would trade careers with Common. That's subjective. The issue is a comparison btwn the two.

The bolded is EXACTLY what the issue is...at least it's entirely what this discussion is about...I responded to a post saying Drake would love to have Common's career, and you responded to my post disagreeing with me...it's not subjective as much is it speculative (based on what we know about Drake and the things he's explicitly said about his intentions and outlook on the game are)...now if you are instead randomly now changing the argument, and attempting to make it which of their careers YOU (subjectively) think is "better" in a hippity hop context...that's fine, but it just doesn't really have shyt to do with me or my post you initially quoted
The core hip hop audience is the audience that can separate the wheat from the chaff so to speak. The listeners who know their history and live and die the music. It's not a regional thing, the core can differentiate between Bun B and Master P. Jay put it best, the core argues all day about whose the best emcees, Biggie, Prodigy and Nas. There's probably 500k or so fans. Artists don't go double platinum off the core. That's casual fans and suburban white kids.
Disagree with this completely, and it's kind of indicative of the short-sightedness and overall folly of the "real hip hop son!" crowd in general....can separate the wheat from the chaff according to who? What are about the hip hop fans that knew their history, live and died the music...but didn't think Biggie, Prodigy (or Jay as he actually said) or Nas were the best? There is no one set of approved opinions that define one to be a "core" or "true" or "real" hip hop fan...opinions are just opinions, some are more widely held than others...but simply opinions all the same...
The core did t lose a culture war. Commerce won out over art and integrity. Hip hop hads no quality control at this point. The major corporations have more sway in defining who "That dude" is then the core.
The core as you're describing it, absolutely did lose the war...acts that were being vilified as killing hip hop by that crowd back then....see: Dr. Dre, Pac, Ice Cube and pretty much the entirety of West Coast Gangsta Rap that Common decried on I USED to Love and Biggie and later his symbolic successor Jay-Z and the entirety of East Coast Flossy Big Willy-ism as attacked by Jeru, BCC and mocked by The Roots....have been now been exalted as hip hop's most holy and iconic figures...people pretend like they were never under fire as the big bad mainstream acts and universally loved, retroactively making them saints in "real hip hop son!' mythology on some Catholic Church tricknology type shyt and just apply that same sentiment to the newer acts making their mark on the current scene (and it's a perpetual process...the real hip hop heads used to crucify Cash Money when they first blew, now all we hear is how much of a classic 400 Degreez and how Mannie Fresh is untouchable rap legend

)...but it's a wrap, that shyt has been out the window...commerce didn't win over art and integrity as much as it became embraced as one of the factors, though not the only one...the corporations dont have more sway than the actual hip hop populace, to me that's just an excuse as to when people don't agree with who the populace has actually chosen...no amount of corporate push is gonna make hip hop go crazy and wild when Macklemore or Flo Rida drops a random remix verse