Breh at this point is there any question about Beyoncé being the female GOAT

[O.T.I.S.]

See, this proves my point. This thread has ran its course for me. I’m out forreal this time.

I literally just answered lmao


I didn’t even know if it was you. I was talking to that queen @Beyonce Knowles-carter until the threads got merged.

Idk who said what first, so any PERSON who said she was better than the GOAT is who I was referring to

 

[proudtobe]

Beyonce is the greatest entertainer alive. I am so proud to be her fan.

 

[IllmaticDelta]

Performance is a minor artistic category.

It's only minor in a pure musical sense. It's major when talking about a complete performer

You can't be the GOAT female musician because you're the best performer. You need to be the best singer. She's not.

there is a difference between a pure musician-vocalist and a artist-performer with above average musicianship and/or vocals. Beyonce is more in the latter category while Aretha and Whitney are in the former. It's the same reason why Tina Turner has always been placed above Whitney and Aretha as a total package instead of vocally where she isn't even close to them.

Beyonce discography is not better than Whitney's. Beyonce biggest hits are not musical gems.

Most of whitney's actual music in the 80's was a disservice to her vocal skills because most of it was watered down trash. That's why she was booed at the soul train awards

Beyoncé is musically better than Whitney???

Get the fukk out of here.

What is wrong with you nikkas? This is what I’m saying. Y’all do too much.

whitney was a supreme vocalist but her music from the 80's was wack...that's why she got booed at the soul train awards

 

[Kilgore Trout]

Bey is OK but not GOAT status


she is the goat for females but as a straight male I dont see how you could sit through a beyonce song or performance

 

[julesocean]

she's musically better than whitney (most of whitney's 80's material was watered down trash aimed at white markets) but inferior to Aretha's

You realize you just described alot of Beyonce's music right? The fact that she has no classic albums is a testament to that.

 

[IllmaticDelta]

All facts^ Super talented singers, but nobody fukks with Beyonce on stage. Can't argue with this logic @African Peasant (btw for all the pro-black militant hypeness there are only 2 Usernames that start with 'African' on The Coli......)

tina turner is the only one

 

[IllmaticDelta]

You realize you just described alot of Beyonce's music right? The fact that she has no classic albums is a testament to that.

beyonce has very few songs made/aimed for white audiences

 

[IllmaticDelta]

I mean what good is singing and dancing if ur music aint worth shyt...
Beyonce doesnt have any fire. People just like her...
Yall comparing her to great artist who actually had a bunch of mega hit songs... fukk singing and dancing lol... thats extra shyt.
Im just saying her music isnt as good as that shorty from the islands... Facts
But this aint my element, so im ghost

rihanna has no talent she ain't on b's level

 

[Illeye buckmatic]

She's up there just not the goat. It's like saying Biggie is top 5 just not better than NaS and Pac That's not a diss to biggie. Still an all time great. Thats beyonce.

 

[Darts]

That's the problem with this generation, always trying to force feed "greatness" instead letting it happen naturally. Same shyt is playing out with Lebron and the other MJ smh.

First rule of greatness...if something is truly great, you don't have to shout it... because everybody already know.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Yeah, I'm convinced.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Some of yall are legit deaf.

Beyonce hit every fukking NOTE in those songs. I was legit SHOCKED.

 

[Real]

She the greatest. Proud of that woman

 

[O.T.I.S.]

That's the problem with this generation, always trying to force feed "greatness" instead letting it happen naturally. Same shyt is playing out with Lebron and the other MJ smh.

First rule of greatness...if something is truly great, you don't have to shout it... because everybody already know.

Exactly

 

[African Peasant]

It's only minor in a pure musical sense. It's major when talking about a complete performer




there is a difference between a pure musician-vocalist and a artist-performer with above average musicianship and/or vocals. Beyonce is more in the latter category while Aretha and Whitney are in the former. It's the same reason why Tina Turner has always been placed above Whitney and Aretha as a total package instead of vocally where she isn't even close to them.




Most of whitney's actual music in the 80's was a disservice to her vocal skills because most of it was watered down trash. That's why she was booed at the soul train awards







whitney was a supreme vocalist but her music from the 80's was wack...that's why she got booed at the soul train awards

What is an artist performer ? It has nothing to do with music. It's not an operational category. it's too wide. Actresses are also performing. People on Broadway are also performing.

Beyonce is a musician, a singer first. Whitney is also a singer, so is Aretha. That's how you compare them.

If you want, Beyonce is the Goat female performer (whatever than means) but she's not the best female singer or musician.

Where do broken heart go >>>>> Formation and Run the world