Dallas Cowboys hire Mike McCarthy as new head coach

smitty22

Is now part of Thee Alliance. Ill die for this ish
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
62,477
Reputation
31,035
Daps
212,102
Keep your head up and trust the process @smitty22
ec7060ff0dae938c88e6c5caacaec524_w200.gif
Garrett gone at least :ufdup: don’t need your shenanigans this fine Monday morning
 

calh45

Cal
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
11,130
Reputation
1,958
Daps
39,778
Marvin is more qualified than MM?

How many playoff games did he win?

One had TWO HOF QBs to work with (Aaron and Brett) along with a competent front office. He rode Aaron during his prime and got a ship after a few years as a mediocre OC. I knew who he was before he became the Packers HC because he coached the 49ers and he was horrible. He was NOT good at all before that either, BUT he was still given a HC job.

The other had two scouts and Mike Brown as an owner who's family still today cheaps their way through seasons. Marv has more years as an HC and an all time defense in his resume as a coordinator.

Don't pretend like the organizations don't matter when it comes to championships and playoffs. He's your former coach, which for some reason is making you defend this shytty hire, but all of the other things matter when it comes to the playoffs. Playoff success has always been a reflection of the organization.
 

FAH1223

Go Wizards, Go Terps, Go Packers!
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
68,588
Reputation
8,017
Daps
208,021
Reppin
WASHINGTON, DC
One had TWO HOF QBs to work with (Aaron and Brett) along with a competent front office. He rode Aaron during his prime and got a ship after a few years as a mediocre OC. I knew who he was before he became the Packers HC because he coached the 49ers and he was horrible. He was NOT good at all before that either, BUT he was still given a HC job.

The other had two scouts and Mike Brown as an owner who's family still today cheaps their way through seasons. Marv has more years as an HC and an all time defense in his resume as a coordinator.

Don't pretend like the organizations don't matter when it comes to championships and playoffs. He's your former coach, which for some reason is making you defend this shytty hire, but all of the other things matter when it comes to the playoffs. Playoff success has always been a reflection of the organization.

Organizations do matter. I like Marvin but he had a lot of chances breh and some of those Bengals teams were talented to get a win in January..
 

Ribbs

Veteran
Joined
May 25, 2015
Messages
20,559
Reputation
3,657
Daps
83,665
Reppin
Toronto
You’re bugging if you thought Urban was getting hired. Jerry’s ego wouldn’t let someone with that big of a name outshine him.
 

Dusty Bake Activate

Fukk your corny debates
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
39,078
Reputation
5,980
Daps
132,631
wait a minute... Y'all didnt criticize Ron Riveras hiring, but Mike McCarthys is bad? lol

Only on the Coli. Outside of receivers, McCarthy never had a potential run threat. He has way more to work with at Dallas.

Y'all bugging.
Yeah people acting like McCarthy is trash in this thread. Maybe his offensive playcalling got stale and needs an upgrade, and he tends to be way too conservative, but dude is a proven winner.

He had A Rod all these years, but remember things turned around in Green Bay in his first year and they made it to their first conference finals in forever after years of stagnation under Mike Sherman and didn’t make the SB cause :upsetfavre: had too much fun out there in OT.

This hire isn’t worthy of laugh smiles. Who were you expecting to get.?
 
Last edited:

RubioTheCruel

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
19,483
Reputation
2,067
Daps
74,016
Reppin
Brooklyn, NY
all of that was not on him

Marvin did a great job with the Bengals however he had teams that had the most talent in the AFC and couldn't win one game in the playoffs. Not all of it was his fault but he was there 16 years and couldn't get out of the wild card round. How much rope do you wanna give a guy?
 

G.O.A.T Squad Spokesman

Logic Is Absent Wherever Hate Is Present
Joined
May 12, 2012
Messages
79,941
Reputation
5,705
Daps
234,942
Id take Lewis. if someone came in for an interview and said they won a chip compared to another very qualified person who didnt? Who you hiring? and you can take color out this.

for as many whiny ass fans we got, I dont feel like hearing the "Lewis never won shyt" narrative for the next year and every other year he dont win it... its already draining hearing all that stuff now,,,
It depends....Brian Billick wishes more owners thought like you tho.
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
45,684
Reputation
6,145
Daps
124,803
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
This is the equivalent of promoting the most average guy in the office because he was salesman of the year back in 09. If he succeeds you as the owner looks good and if he fails you can fire him and blame it on his mediocrity. In other this a safe Cowboy move that does nothing to move the needle and keep the Cowboys teetering between 7-9 or 9-7 with a maybe a 10 win season or two sprinkled in. If you were going to do this, you may have well as kept Garrett.
 
Top