How did Peyton Manning survive so many underwhelming playoff performances? His defenses weren't bad

[Formerly known as...]

Remember when people compared Peyton and Rodgers to Brady

I do miss watching Peyton run an offense though.

 

[PortCityProphet]

Coli always has and always will be "in the moment" ass nikkas. Its why some of these hottakes in here are unbearable. And the fact they apply NBA hottakes in football makes it ten times worse.

I know i troll and talk shyt at times because thats why i got hooked on SOHH due to the comedy aspect of that forum....it sure as hell wasnt for the sports talk


Theres a handful of brehs in here who actual keep it level headed and kick good knowledge tho.

Preciate your compliment to me breh

 

[nairdas]

I

U truly are a retarded casual. Manning was trash that SB run. He got carried by his D.

I know what he was the run but he sure wasn't trash when he had to bring the Colts back against the Patriots in the Afc championship game now was he? Aaron will never have an all time great playoff game in his life like that. And Peyton didn't have to do much in the SB because the Bears were trash.

 

[nairdas]

His coach went for a FG instead of a TD but thats rodgers fault right? Idiot

Just know Rodgers playoff stats shyts on Mannings and by your retarded logic Aikman And Bradshaw are better then Manning. Two SB appearances what a scrub


Too bad Manning cant get on Aikman or Bradshaws level

Two sb appearances??? nikka try 4. Can Aaron bytch ass even get to another one?? IT'S BEEN 12 YEARS

Talk to me when Aaron breaks all the records like Peyton was doing in his prime. Aaron will never have the yards and TDs all time. NEVER.

Oh but Peyton did at one point tho

Real GOAT shyt.

 

[TaxCollector13459]

What you are saying does not hold up under scrutiny.

Did you not actually watch the videos? Or games?

The whole point is that Peyton DID NOT HAVE TO BE PERFECT.



Peyton's defenses actually played almost as good as Bradys in the playoffs. You're still sticking to the narrative too much. When you dissect it, they were not much worse than the Pats

What about the 2003 Panthers Super Bowl?

That was one of the few years NE was loaded on the defensive side. We shoulda won, if it wasnt for John Kasay and that kick off penalty.

Indy had good players on d, but NE has had better players overall

 

[Luck]

Colts defense and Rex gross man won manning his first super bowl too. That 5 head inbred is the definition of a choke artist that gets bailed out by his team when it counts.

 

[No1]

That was one of the few years NE was loaded on the defensive side. We shoulda won, if it wasnt for John Kasay and that kick off penalty.

Indy had good players on d, but NE has had better players overall

That’s the point, Brady found ways to win even when his defense wasn’t the greatest.

 

[Shadow King]

Nah he's definitely overrated. He his d gave him 3 extra tries this past NFC championship game and he only scored 6 points. Aaron not what yall think he is regardless of his trash D.

Yes because the opposing defense actually played at an NFL level when necessary while his let the score get run up in the first place

 

[Frump]

How young are you? He got tons of Sh1t

He also maybe the greatest regular season QB ever so that counts for something.

Also as far as his D they were good when Peyton got them a lead and they could pin their ears back because they had 2 really good pass rushers and Bob Sanders was very good

Outside of that they weren’t very good.

The Chiefs Colts playoff game no team punted he needed to score 50 to win

 

[TaxCollector13459]

Brad

That’s the point, Brady found ways to win even when his defense wasn’t the greatest.

I mean it was a gimme after that..

 

[Lootpack]

Coli always has and always will be "in the moment" ass nikkas. Its why some of these hottakes in here are unbearable. And the fact they apply NBA hottakes in football makes it ten times worse.

I know i troll and talk shyt at times because thats why i got hooked on SOHH due to the comedy aspect of that forum....it sure as hell wasnt for the sports talk


Theres a handful of brehs in here who actual keep it level headed and kick good knowledge tho.

You’re right, but you’re also one of them.

 

[No1]

Brad



I mean it was a gimme after that..

A defense giving up 29 isn’t a gimme.

 

[Bboystyle]

You’re right, but you’re also one of them.

Thats why i clearly said i know i do it at times

 

[prime]

Colts defense and Rex gross man won manning his first super bowl too. That 5 head inbred is the definition of a choke artist that gets bailed out by his team when it counts.

i can't really blame rex on that lost the defense gave up 250 yards rushing and ron turner called a shyt game both benson and jones should've have had 15+ carries ron turner dumbass only called 15 run plays I know this is off topic but that game really get me fukking upset the bears really should've won that game

 

[TaxCollector13459]

A defense giving up 29 isn’t a gimme.

It was a gimme for the defense after john Kasey gave them half field position gang... 29-31. I remember that game well like yesterday, even though I was a jit.

I disagree about indy having a good defense compared to NE. That was probably arguably the strongest complete defense NE has ever put on the gridiron

Mike v, teddy bruschi, willie mcginest, ty law, teddy Washington, richard Seymour, rodney harrison?? Like come on bra.. that's a pro bowler/all pro at damn near every position . Peyton may have had good players but as a whole, hell naw, they wasnt fukking with NE.